- Review: Explore Scientific 16”, Europe edition, late 2016
- VITE 2X Barlow Lens Review
- Sky Commander Review
- Wireless Control of Canon EOS DSLRs with DSLR Controller and TP-Link MR3040 W...
- Review of the 18” f/5 Otte binodobson
- Wireless Telescope Control for Celestron (and Compatible) Scopes
- A Review of Teeter STS18
- MesuMount 200 Review
- First Light with the Prototype 8x42 Space WalkerTM 3D Binoculars
- INTERSTELLARUM DEEP-SKY ATLAS (FIELD EDITION) REVIEW
- THE BAADER BBHS-SITALL SILVER DIAGONAL
- Explore Scientific AR 102
- Review: davejlec's Paralellogram Mount
- Annals of the Deep Sky, Volumes One and Two
- Discovery 17.5” Split Tube Dobsonian Telescope
CNers have asked about a donation box for Cloudy Nights over the years, so here you go. Donation is not required by any means, so please enjoy your stay.
ARP ATLAS OF PECULIAR GALAXIES, A Chronicle and Observer’s Guide
Discuss this article in our forums
ARP ATLAS OF PECULIAR GALAXIES, A Chronicle and Observer’s Guide
The Arp Atlas1
by Jeff Kanipe and Dennis Webb, 8.5x11, 400 pages, $39.95 from Willmann-Bell
The Arp Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies, a Chronicle and Observer’s Guide is unlike any atlas you may have looked at before. Yes, it has charts (27 including the key), but it features a collection of unusual galaxies the likes of which most people have never seen. Most of us have seen M51, the Whirlpool Galaxy. And in fact, there are 10 other Messier objects in the Atlas. But M51 is only the tip of the iceberg, as it is a deformed galaxy with a companion on an arm. In the Atlas there are galaxies with “Counter-Tails, Rings, Jets, ‘Wind’ Effects, Plumes, Galaxy Chains, Single- and Multi- Armed Galaxies and other oddities”. 1
DISCOVERY OF ‘PECULIAR GALAXIES’: In the period of 1949-1958, the Palomar Observatory Sky Survey (POSS-1), sponsored by the National Geographic Institute, was conducted for the northern sky. The area covered was from the celestial north pole to -27° declination and all right ascensions to a sensitivity of +22 Magnitude. The field of view was 6°x6°. About 950 plate-pairs were used using blue and red-sensitive Kodak material. This survey was done with the 48” Oschin Schmidt telescope on Palomar Mountain. After publication, Dr. Halton C. Arp began a study of some peculiar galaxies discovered by other astronomers, namely Zwicky (who conducted the survey) and Vorontsov-Velyaminov. After culling a number of candidates from NGC-POSS-I survey, Dr. Arp sampled high-resolution photographs with the Palomar 200-inch telescope. In reviewing the new images, he realized a new system of classification was needed as none of his selections fit the classic Hubble “Tuning Fork” Classification Scheme.
Hubble’s Tuning Fork 2
ARP’S CLASSIFICATIONS: As a result of his studies, Dr. Arp developed 5 categories with 39 sub-categories as shown on page 10 of the new Atlas. The classifications were based upon similar characteristics found in the samples.
The above figures are from the Original Edition available online at Caltech3
ORIGINAL EDITION: The Original Edition was published in 1966. While it is now out-of-print, it can be found online here: http://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/Arp/frames.html3. The Atlas contained about 100 pages consisting of a few introductory pages and 85 pages of 4 images per page of the negative plates of Dr. Arp’s 338 selected irregular galaxies.
Arp’s Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies was not well received by his peers at the time. They claimed the presentation was not significant enough statistically to be of interest (about 1-2% of all catalogued stars). Besides, astrophysics then did not have the tools to explain the formation of galaxies, let alone their morphing: Peculiars were simply not worth pursuing.
In 1973 the United Kingdom Science Research Council began a deep Southern Sky Survey similar to its northern counterpart using the 48” Schmidt in Australia which is a twin of the one at Mt. Palomar. Over the course of 7 years, Dr.Arp and Barry Madore examined 77,838 galaxies on 537 plates and found 6445 galaxies that were peculiar. This was 8%, not just 1-2% as in the northern survey. Peculiar galaxies could no longer be ignored. In 1987, Arp and Madore published A Catalogue of peculiar Galaxies and Associations. It is available online at Caltech: http://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/SPGA_Atlas/frames.html
However, these findings still did not sway the mainstream astronomers who considered peculiars as freaks and did not matter statistically. Two things would change that:
First, “astronomers have classified galaxies according to their appearance at visual wavelengths - in blue light. But the advent of radio, ultraviolet, and near-infrared observations has shown that a galaxy’s appearance can substantially morph with wavelength. A normal spiral can appear distinctly abnormal depending on whether it is seen in ultraviolet or near-infrared light. Dust as well as its core energy output can also affect a galaxy’s appearance at wavelengths other than those in the visual band.
“The second development didn’t dawn until 1995 and 1996 when the Hubble Deep Fields North and South brought to light thousands of previously unknown fragmented and distorted galaxies extending out to the edge of the visible Universe, each within a parcel of sky no larger than a pin-point. Assuming these two opposing directions were not special exceptions to the overall distribution of galaxies, there had to be tens of billions of such galaxies dispersed across the sky. The remarkable Hubble Ultra Deep Field, released in March of 2004, has further confirmed this.
“Taken together, the multi-wavelength observations and deep-field findings have significantly altered astrophysicists’ idea of what a normal galaxy is. In fact, there are no “normal” galaxies. As Arp presciently wrote in his preface to Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies, ‘when looked at closely enough, every galaxy is peculiar’.”4
REPUBLISHED in 2006: Forty years later authors Jeff Kanipe and Dennis Webb have extensively expanded the Arp Atlas, and added the annotation to the title “A Chronicle and Observer’s Guide”. The revised Atlas has 400 pages with 42 pages of original images. The new ‘Chronicle’ section has about 70 pages of history and orientation, and 26 Charts (A-Z) showing the location of all Arps. The Observing Guide has over 230 pages, combining CCD images taken by amateur observers of all 338 Arp galaxies, annotated schematic diagrams of each galaxy field and observers’ notes. This Atlas is both an encyclopedia and a working guide. More detail on the new and revised sections follows:
• “A Chronicle…” Roughly 70 pages in the Chronicle cover the following topics:
- The processes that make galaxies peculiar
- Halton Arp’s early life
- His initial work at Mount Wilson
- How and why he constructed the Atlas
- Why he left the Carnegie Institute
- The breakup between Carnegie and Caltech
- His controversial work on galaxy-quasar associations
- Profiles of some of Arp’s most prominent discordant redshift cases
• Republishing Original Scans:
“The Atlas reprint contains prints from scans of intermediate photographic prints provided by Barry Madore which were several processing steps away from the original glass plates and were then used for the composite printing of the original Atlas” 5. These have been adjusted somewhat to remove artifacts, scratches, etc., and are printed in the original Arp sequence annotated with the most common galaxy name, Chart letter and Observing Guide Page number. All 338 Arps are presented. Shown below is the 1st page of plates 1:
• … “And Observing Guide”: These 230 pages consist of a Chart Key, 26 Charts showing the locations by Constellation of all 338 Arp galaxies (which I refer to as ‘Arps’ from here on), Tables of Chart characteristics on the facing page, a collection of CCD images of the Arps in the Chart and notes from amateur astronomers on the pages following each chart. Examples are shown below:
• Chart B1:
• Chart B Information on facing Page1 (Ra/Dec = J2000):
• CCD Images of several Arps per page. Note: in the lower pair of images, the original Arp field is in a white background annotated with its size in arc-minutes: 2.7’ and 11’ respectively on this particular page1:
BRIGHTNESS AND SIZE OF ARPS: The Arps range in Magnitudes all the way down to 18.0 with a field size from 68 x 53 arc-minutes (Arp 317, Leo Triplet) down to 2.2 x 1.7 arc-minutes. Two thirds of the image fields are 3.6 arcminutes or smaller. Many may be either too dim or too small for you to fully appreciate without specialized equipment. 6
Illustration by Dennis Webb 7
Histogram by Dennis Webb 8
This is a case where the size of your equipment rules! But even scopes of 8” ~ 10” can satisfactorily see the brighter and larger Arps. Those of you with CCD imaging capability can image even smaller and dimmer Arps. Accordingly, here is a list of 19 of the brightest Arps >=Mag 12.1 arranged by Arp Number as a starting point for you to explore a world of objects few others have seen:
|BIG AND BRIGHT ARPS|
|1||16||3627||M66||9.7||11.0||11 20.25||+12 59.3||Leo|
|2||26||5457||M101||7.9||34.0||14 3.21||+54 24.0||UMa|
|3||37||1068||M77||8.9||3.6||2 42.67||0 0.8||Cet|
|4||76||4569||M90||10.3||11.0||12 36.79||+13 11.4||Vir|
|5||77||1097||9.2||11.0||2 46.27||-30 15.5||For|
|6||84||5395-5394||M90||11.4||5.5||13 58.58||+37 26.0||CVn|
|7||85||5197-5195||M51||8.4||23.0||13 29.87||+47 11.9||CVn|
|8||94||3226-3557||11.1||11.0||10 23.45||+19 51.9||Leo|
|9||116||4649||M60||9.8||11.0||12 43.66||+11 33.2||Vir|
|10||120||4438-4435||10.1||11.0||12 27.76||+13 2.0||Vir|
|11||153||5128||6.8||23.0||13 25.46||-43 1,1||Cen|
|12||244||4038-4039||11.1||22.0||12 1.83||-18 54.0||Crv|
|13||269||4490-4485||Cocoon||10.2||11.0||12 30.50||+41 39.5||CVn|
|14||270||3395-3396||12.1||3.6||10 49.88||+32 59.0||LMi|
|15||281||4631-4627||9.8||23.0||12 42.10||+32 32.4||CVn|
|16||286||5566 Group||Antenna||11.5||11.0||14 20.25||+ 3 57.0||Vir|
|17||317||Leo Triplet||9.7||68.0||11 19.30||+13 17.0||Leo|
|18||318||833 Group||12.1||11.0||2 9.46||-10 9.0||Cet|
|19||337||3034||M82||8.4||11.0||9 55.86||+69 40.8||UMa|
WHERE DO YOU FIND MORE INFORMATION ON THE ARPS? Information about Arps is somewhat difficult to find since most Atlases do not list them. Then there is the problem of different synonyms. While the Observing Guide pinpoints the locations of all Arps, you may wish to look up additional information such as Distance, Red-Shift, etc. Star catalogues list some of them. For example there are 11 Messier objects, 29 Herschels, and 18 Hicksons. (See this list on Doug Webb’s site: http://arpgalaxy.com/intersec.html.) His website also lists about 15 other sources.
Stellarium searches use Simbad which returns an NGC number and sky position without selecting an object: you have to select a nearby star to freeze the motion. At least you can find the constellation and general location by zooming out, or use the NGC number to consult other references.
Another excellent online source is the NASA/Ipac Extra Galactic Database (http://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/). I found 10 synonyms for Arp 192 and 46 for Arp 77! Of course the best place to find them is in the Atlas as they are listed both in Arp sequence and Ra/Dec by constellation in the Appendix along with finder charts by constellation in the Observer’s Guide.
In preparing this article, I had the opportunity to visit Jeff Kanipe’s website several times. http://jeffkanipe.wordpress.com/ On one of my visits, I noticed the following fascinating vignette, reprinted with the permission of Jeff Kanipe:
THE MYSTERY OF THE MISSING SPIKE IN THE GALAXY ARP 192
“An odd feature that for more than 40 years was thought to be structurally associated with a peculiar galaxy has been identified as the superposed trail of a main-belt asteroid that happened to be crossing the galaxy as it was being photographed in 1964. An amateur astronomer who imaged the galaxy in 2008 first noted the modern lack of the ‘spike.’
“The mystery begins in 1966, when astronomer Halton C. Arp published a compilation of 338 photographs of highly asymmetrical galaxies and galaxy groups taken at Palomar Mountain in Southern California. Entitled “The Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies,” the book was one of the first serious inquiries into the nature of what was, at the time, a small class of disturbed galactic systems that were neither spiral nor elliptical in form. One of these galaxies, number 192 (also known as NGC 3303), has a distinctive spike appearing to jut from the galaxy’s bulbous northwest side. Based on its appearance in the Arp Atlas, Peter Nilson described the feature as a “sharp jet” in his 1973 Uppsala Galaxy Catalogue.
“Forty years after the Atlas was published, two astronomy writers, Jeff Kanipe and Dennis Webb, published their commemorative book “The Arp Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies: A Chronicle and Observer’s Guide“ (Willmann-Bell, 2006). The book recounts Arp’s research leading to the compilation of the Atlas and reproduces all of the original Atlas images, along with modern images made by amateur astronomers. Ironically, the authors ranked the Arp 192 spike/jet as a “challenge” for advanced amateurs to photograph.
“In August 2009, Kanipe and Webb learned that an amateur astronomer in Minnesota, Rick Johnson, had made a deep image of Arp 192, one he thought should have revealed the spike’s presence. Johnson reported, however, that the spike was not visible. Suspecting that Johnson’s exposure probably had not gone deep enough, Kanipe consulted recent images of Arp 192, the best being from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. He inverted the image to a negative format, converted it to gray scale, and then contrast-enhanced it so the resulting image approximated the density of the one in the Atlas. No vestige of the spike was apparent. It had truly vanished. “This was an exciting turn of events, and not a little disturbing,” says Kanipe. “Galactic structures do change, but they change over periods of several hundred million years. The human race hasn’t existed long enough to observe dramatic structural changes in any galaxy, but here was a feature that had evaporated in 40 years, and nobody noticed.” Possible explanations for the spike’s conspicuous absence included it having been a photographic artifact, a plate defect, or an asteroid trail. The orbits of thousands of minor planets have been so well determined that by calculating “backward” in time one can ascertain an asteroid’s position on any day in the past. Archivists at the Carnegie Observatories headquarters in Pasadena, California, confirmed to Kanipe that the original plate was taken on 19 February 1964. Brian Marsden, director emeritus of the Minor Planet Center at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics in Cambridge, Massachusetts, subsequently confirmed that minor planet (84447) 2002 TU240 would have been located near the sky coordinates for Arp 192 on that date in 1964. With that, the mystery was solved. The asteroid was discovered on 6 October 2002 by the Near Earth Asteroid Telescope on Haleakala, Maui, Hawaii. The Arp 192 Atlas image is the earliest known prediscovery image of this object. Just after Thanksgiving 2009, Kanipe learned from Marsden that minor planet (84447) 2002 TU240, now bore a different name: 84447 Jeffkanipe. The extraordinary coincidence of an asteroid trail being captured as it happened to transit a small peculiar galaxy understandably led to the erroneous conclusion that the spike was an intrinsic feature. Thereafter, it became part of the astronomical literature; if not for the question posed by an amateur astronomer, it might still be.” 9
Left Image: Original 1964 image of Arp 192 with “spike” in upper right (Shown as positive) 3
Right: 2008 Image by Rick Johnson, NO SPIKE 10
Here is a wide-field large image taken by Rick where you can see two Minor Planet trails SW of the Arp near the triangle of bright stars: 11
Rick Johnson has a fascinating post on CN telling his side of the story and shows both the side-by-side and wide-field views above:
•Wikipedia: On this site you will find a 42 page article entitled Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies. After a brief introduction, the Contents list all 338 of Dr. Arp’s peculiars in the 5 categories and 39 sub-categories. Following the Contents is a listing of Arps in sequence with a synonym and notes. Most interesting are the 40 color photographs of selected galaxies which are breath-taking. 4 of these are shown below:
Arp 85, M51, the Whirlpool, Companion on Arm 12
Arp 148 Mayall’s Object, With Associated Rings 12
Arp 194, Material Ejected From Nuclei 12
Arp 242, the Mice Galaxies, Appearance of Fission 12
12 These (4) images are from : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_of_Peculiar_Galaxies
FURTHER READING: Below are several sites you may wish to visit:
•Astronomical League: They have an Arp Observer’s Club which gives recognition to those who have visually observed or imaged 100 of the peculiar views.
•Dennis Webb’s Website: This is a great site, a good read with over 100 links to reference material. There is a very funny and well-written account of his research saga starting in 1995 to compile a catalogue of synonyms, data location, field size, magnitudes, etc. (http://arpgalaxy.com/story/index.html).
Dennis’ Website: http://arpgalaxy.com/
CONCLUSION: Both Arp’s original and new editions are important in the evolution of astronomy. The information is well presented: the Chronicle alone is an important piece of history. The stories behind both the original and new editions are truly amazing and well worth the read. If you are a DSO observer, the Atlas is a “must-have’. If you already have the Atlas, I hope I have been able to share new material for you. One tip if you are imaging the Arps: Arp 148 is receding at 10,171 km/s which is about 21,969,360 MPH. You may want to consider 10 minute exposures rather than 100 minute exposures so the object does not drift out of your field of view.
SPECIAL THANKS: Thanks to Willmann-Bell, Dennis Webb, Jeff Kanipe and Rick Johnson for their generous permission to use their material in this article.
CREDITS of sources used in Article:
1. Arp Atlas Willman-Bell http://www.willbell.com/HANDBOOK/arp.htm
2. Hubble Tuning Fork NASA/ESA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:HubbleTuningFork.jpg
3. Original Atlas Caltech http://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/Arp/frames.html
4. Arp Atlas, Page xiv Willmann-Bell Reprinted with permission
5. Arp Atlas, Page 10 Willmann-Bell Reprinted with permission
6. Website Dennis Webb http://arpgalaxy.com/
7. Scale of Arp Galaxies Dennis Webb http://arpgalaxy.com/arpscale.jpg
8. Histogram of Mags Dennis Webb http://arpgalaxy.com/magdist.jpg
9. Website Jeff Kanipe http://jeffkanipe.wordpress.com/
10. CN post (See above) Rick Johnson
12. Arp Photos Wikipedia NASA/ESA
“The difference between Stupidity and Genius, Genius has its limits.” Albert Einstein