Posted 11 September 2012 - 02:15 PM
Posted 11 September 2012 - 02:17 PM
Posted 14 October 2012 - 09:22 PM
I now ask for donations and do not formally charge for telescope views. I leave it up the the viewers to put in money of they so desire.
I have noticed how I get absolutely NO donations when I do outreach in affluent areas, but I do get donation in middle class and poor neighborhoods. It leaves a bad taste in my mouth to see this.
Posted 19 October 2012 - 09:32 PM
This is the second time I've looked in this forum (first time was years ago) and this was the first thread I clicked on. Imagine my dismay to find that I have been the topic of an online discussion started months ago
Reading through the comments I felt somewhat compelled to address the speculation concerning me:
Something not mentioned: perhaps he was a victim of the Waldo canyon fire in the springs and is trying to make extra to help rebuild or just take care of his family. Could be a big assumption on my part but just to throw it out there...
Fortunately my dwelling was not consumed by the fire, although it was right on the evac line. I count my lucky star on that one.
After getting laid-off from a job I had held for nearly seven years, I decided to go back to school and better my prospects. While I should have saved to make this possible when times were good, I didn't. Being in the position I was, I had to think of another way. This is right around the time the sun was throwing its first real temper tantrum of the summer, and I thought it was a shame that so few people get to witness our star putting on the amazing and violent display that it does. I made a sign, got a little basket, a rock that reads "Help solar power my college", a stool for the kids and a parasol and went to the most touristy place I could think of near colorado springs.
I am now currently enrolled in school full-time with no need for a part time job at the moment, due to my outreach efforts this summer. Regardless of how you feel about how I'm going about it, I doubt I'd be doing what I am without it.
Many posters are using the word charging, when accepting is more appropriate.
I put free views on my sign and I mean it. It is a joy to allow people to see their star in a way they might never have seen it otherwise. The telescope they look through is a 60mm dedicated Ha scope that is doublestacked with an additional Ha filter to increase surface contrast, so the view isn't shabby.
If I hear a person saying to their friend that they would like to look but they didn't bring any change, I encourage them to look, saying my primary goal is to share the view with others. I estimate that out of every 10 people that look, 3 may leave something in the basket. A lot of people are profusely thankful, especially parents who beam over their children experiencing something new.
The scope could have been acquired under different circumstances. It could be like if you have a cow, do you sell the cow or the milk?
I bought the scope before losing my job, and have never considered selling it. Though my situation might have gotten to the point where I would have been forced to. Thankfully I discovered it's udders are endlessly full of sun (at least when it's clear).
I think it would have been interesting had you taken a moment and asked the fellow about it and how he felt. You probably would have had a clearer understanding.
You should have, I am not shy in explaining to anyone what it is I am doing regarding the outreach. The way I look at it, what better way to fund my education than by educating others?
Heck, I'd probably stick the poor devil with some of my astro-gear overflow and he would never again put out the box.
Is that an offer? My mount is falling apart... I assume you were jesting and so am I.
That is unless you really do want to send me stuff... (I'd pay the shipping)
Personally, I am a big fan of being fed dinner when I do outreach. After all, we often do this around dinner time, and don't always have time to eat or drink for the 2-4 hours we're on the lawn or in the parking lot.
This summer I had a lady bring me a bottle of local ginger ale from south carolina. Man was it good!
My reward comes when I show someone Saturn for the first time. I had a cousin come out to our observatory with a boy scout troop. He said that was the best night of his life.
This activity does have it's own rewards and often it is quite humbling. Like hearing someone exclaim "That is the coolest thing I've ever seen!", while at the same time being surrounded by the majesty of Garden of the Gods. Maybe someday I can do this without having to ask the public for anything in return. I sure enjoy it enough!
I'm in no way offended by this thread, in fact I am thrilled, and view this discussion as a very healthy thing.
Posted 20 October 2012 - 01:34 AM
Posted 20 October 2012 - 03:47 PM
I attribute this to the nature of our national parks ranger programs, which are free, and Americans have come to expect this. I have been told that Europeans are more likely to
pay for this type of program. In addition national parks are not as common elsewhere as in the U.S.
Since my goal is to show the sky to as many people as possible any deterrent, such as a fee to view or even the question of a fee, defeats my efforts.
For these reasons I feel outreach must not have any economic component. Any doubts in the visitors mind only discourages his participation.
Posted 11 November 2012 - 11:55 AM
The original post said that the guy had a sign that indicated that viewing was free. I don't see where he was actually charging to look. So, just as with our club, people can donate or not and nobody has to make a stink about it.