Charlie Hein
(Postmaster)
02/12/08 07:12 AM
Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Welcome to the January 2008 Cloudy Nights Imaging/Sketching Contest poll!

Each month the best images selected from the individual Cloudy Nights Imaging and Sketching forums will be presented for the userbase to vote on. The monthly winner receives the coveted Cloudy Nights t-shirt! At the conclusion of the poll, the entry with the highest total will be the winner of the contest..

Please choose your favorite out of all the images. This poll will remain open through February 15th at midnight EST.


Here are the entries for January!


Beginning Imaging's Finalist - Strgazr27:



4 Hours of M81/82.

Intes MN74
Self Modded 40D
80X180sec
Darks, Flats and Bias
IP version 3, Registar and PSCS2
CGE
DSIPro/PHD/GPUSB for guiding


Film Astrophotography's Finalist - AstroBobo:



Here's M42 taken with Pentax 105 SDP and Pentax 6x7 medium format camera on Fuji Provia 400X. This is a composite of three exposures - 40 min, 6 min and 1 min, to show the detail in the brightest part of the nebula. The image is a bit cropped. Also, I left the background slightly brighter on purpose, to show the darker, outer parts of the nebula.

Taken from Petrova Gora, Croatia.


DSLR & Digital Camera Astro Imaging & Processing's Finalist - Mike B.:


8p Tuttle/M33 Encounter

(Click the image for an enlargement.)

Name: Mike Broussard
Location: Maurice, LA
Dates: Oct 6, Dec 4, Dec 30, 2007
Telescope: Televue TV-85 APO w/0.8x Focal Reducer/Field Flattener (F/5.6, 480mm F.L.)
Camera: Hutech Modified Canon 350XT w/IDAS-LPS Front Filter
Mount: Atlas EQ-G w/EQMOD
Guiding: 140mm F/3.6 Schmidt-Newt, DSI Pro, PHD Guiding
Exposure: 81x60 sec @ ISO 1600 of the comet and M33 combined with 30x300 sec @ ISO 1600 of M33 taken with the TV-85 on Dec 4, 2007. Additional 27x180 sec @ ISO 1600 of M33 taken with SN-8 on Oct 6, 2007.
Processing: IRIS, Registar, PS, Gradient XTerminator, Neat Image & Noel Carboni's Astronomy Tools


CCD Imaging & Processing's Finalist - Jim Lafferty:



IC 1805, the "heart" of the Heart Nebula in Narrowband, from Redlands, Ca. Imaged with my FSQ106N and ST2000xm with astrodon filters. Guided on my NJP mount with an sbig e-finder/remote guide head assembly. Ha-SII-Ha-OIII. unbinned for a total exposure time of 14.2 hours,on the nights of November 14, 15, 18, 19, and December 3 and 4, 2007 from my Skyshed POD. Ha was 280 minutes, SII was 280 minutes and OIII was 300 minutes, unbinned. Processed with Maxim DL, CCD Stack, and Photoshop CS2.

Larger version:

http://www.scopetrader.com/Photography/Photos/3880274.jpg


Solar System Imaging's Finalist - iceman:



Clavius Mosaic

Date: 30th December 2007
Location: Central Coast, NSW Australia
Telescope: 12" newt on EQ6
Camera: DMK21AU04 + 5x powermate + astronomik R filter

Full version here. (300kb jpeg)


Sketching Forum's Finalist - Erika Rix:



PCW Memorial Observatory, Lat: 40.01 Long: -81.56
Sun in H-alpha featuring NOAA 10980 and 10981
2008 01 04, 1720UT - 1820UT

Equipment:
DS Maxscope 60mm, 40mm Pro Optic Plossl, 21-7mm Zhumell Zoom, LXD 75

Sketch Media:
Black Strathmore Artagain paper
White Conte’ Crayon and pencil
White Prang pencil
Charcoal
White vinyl eraser
Black pen

Post processing:
Scanned in Photoshop, added contrast and subtracted brightness, resized and arranged collage. Digital sun insert from Tilting Sun program.




Good Luck to all our finalists!


johndouk
(member)
02/12/08 08:23 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

WOW !
What a selection trouble again...
I think that every month it gets even more difficult...

Congrats to all! Amazing work !!!


mmgoddard
(newbie)
02/14/08 01:35 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

My first post and all I can say is wow! Fantastic images from everyone...

astrodude
(member)
02/14/08 01:45 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Simply stunning! All the images are very nice, I really liked the sketching but in the end I voted for the lunar surface (easily the best I have seen).

boyd
(sage)
02/14/08 01:57 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

All make my feeble efforts look...err...well...feeble

bravo to all!


Mike B
(Starstruck)
02/14/08 02:52 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

A truly brutal decision... they were ALL incredible!
Way to go, everyone


sam32
(super member)
02/14/08 02:54 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

There were at least 3 that I thought were amazing. I felt guilty just picking one. Keep up the truly excellent work all !!

Sam


Nick Cook
(Pooh-Bah)
02/14/08 03:55 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

That was a very tough choice. Erica – your solar sketches just get better and better. However, with so many fantastic entries and a lot of head scratching, in the end I had to go for Mike B. That was a fantastic composition to pull off. Congrats.

Nick


Middle Age Man
(member)
02/14/08 04:01 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

I wish my results could be even a quarter as good as these are.

ilias200400
(newbie)
02/14/08 04:18 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Fantastic images!

Ibmelrod
(newbie)
02/14/08 05:37 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

I would have voted for all of them if it were allowed. Each is deserving of a big shout-out. Wow!
Mel R.


m.r.memarian
(super member)
02/14/08 05:37 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Hi,

Ultra tough decision! Brilliant Pictures.


Illinois
(professor emeritus)
02/14/08 05:55 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

All is good! Diffcult for me to just one vote! Sketching the Sun is really great! I picked M33 and comet because its so rare to have both in one photo!

Saso
(newbie)
02/14/08 06:10 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

This is really hard to decide. I also picked M33 and comet not only because is rare but because I like it very much. Moon shot is also fantastic. And others too of course.

F.Meiresonne
(Post Laureate)
02/14/08 06:20 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Extra-ordinary pictures.

Especially Clavius, what a detail and that with a 12" newt....just incredible...


Philz
(member)
02/14/08 06:30 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Chosing only one was too hard, I voted for the Lunar shot, great detail to the others all I can say is Im not worthy

Phil


Sol
(Carpal Tunnel)
02/14/08 07:05 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

M33 and Comet for me too as that was not only technically difficult and brilliantly executed, but an extremely rare event.

David Culp
(Pooh-Bah)
02/14/08 07:08 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

How come there isnt an "all of the above" button?

mblack
(Throw me a bone here)
02/14/08 08:06 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

My choice was easy

FAB
(Stargeezer)
02/14/08 08:14 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Clavius has always fascinated me. It still does, even after voting for it. A great bunch of imaging. Congratulations to all.
FAB


john D
(All you have to do is ask!!)
02/14/08 08:32 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Strgazr27 shot was great!

John Jenks
(newbie)
02/14/08 08:45 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

I'll go with the simple beauty M81/M82. But the others I would love to print and hang in the office. I do some photo stuff and I'm sooooo jealous. Great job guys.

kcgolden
(super member)
02/14/08 09:08 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

The moon mosaic by "iceman" is so cool. It almost has a 3 dimensional effect and makes me feel as though I'm a few miles above the surface!

Photon
(sage)
02/14/08 09:08 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

I have to protest. These are fanatastic -- all of them. I can't choose. In fact, I don't think we should be pitting photos against sketches. That's kind of like having a contest where a gymnast competes against a singer -- who's better?

That's my humble opinion, anyway... Pete


Carol L
()
02/14/08 09:12 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Mike's 'Clavius' image is my favorite..
absolutely stunning!


cocobolo
(Carpal Tunnel)
02/14/08 09:22 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

We owe a debt of gratitude to everyone who has gone to so much trouble to produce all these great images. I had an awful time trying to pick just one. I think it would be better if we could vote for 1-2-3-4-5 and have a simple weighted system to tally up the winner. Kind of like figure skating. All the scores from all the judges are added up to get a better overall average. Just a thought. A HUGE thank you to all the participants. Keith

insinu8
(sage)
02/14/08 10:30 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Each was spectacular, so it wasn't an easy choice. I had to keep going back to each one to ponder on it a while.

The one that I came back to most frequently though, was Clavius, so that's my vote.


w orchid
(scholastic sledgehammer)
02/14/08 10:51 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Awesome job guys.

sunnynights
(member)
02/14/08 11:24 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

-Another vote for "they were all magnificent" category. They all had exceptional strong points. Uh, is there any chance the T-shirt could be divided five ways? Or maybe just give out five this month?

tubie
(newbie)
02/14/08 11:42 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Yes, all are magnificent, stunning and spectacular. Every one is a winner.

gripweed44
(scholastic sledgehammer)
02/15/08 12:03 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

WOW

all of these are absolutely GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Heres to all of your great work!!


Yossi Hury
(member)
02/15/08 04:07 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

I would shoose the lunar picture, but ERIKA'S sketch is hard to beat.

YOSSI


jarbi
(newbie)
02/15/08 04:32 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Hi,

All amazing pictures, very difficault to choose. My vote goes to iceman - a breathtaking close-up !

cheers,
Janos


JMG
(newbie)
02/15/08 07:03 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Jim Lafferty's Heart Nebula in Narrowband is the favorite.

star toucher
(member)
02/15/08 07:20 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Can 6 t-shirts be awarded? But (sigh) as always I am forced to choose only one -- it wasn't easy.....

Bernard Murdoch
(member)
02/15/08 09:29 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

This is my first time voting. All the images are outstanding and I can't really tell which is technically the most difficult. Yes, I know, they all are! Anyhow, I just voted from the Wow! side of the brain.

Erix
(Toad Lily)
02/15/08 10:11 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Quote:

That was a very tough choice. Erica – your solar sketches just get better and better. However, with so many fantastic entries and a lot of head scratching, in the end I had to go for Mike B. That was a fantastic composition to pull off. Congrats.

Nick




Thanks, Nick. The Sun has been such an interesting target to learn about and I've been having fun trying to make as accurate recordings as I can in the process.

Mike B's M33 and Tuttle is fantastic as well as the others. This imaging contest is certainly helping to show what amazing images can be achieved by amateurs with a variety of tools. Well done, everyone!


zantespear
(member)
02/15/08 02:42 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

I simply can 't vote... they are all amazing

astroleo
(journeyman)
02/15/08 04:34 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Amazing Pics.. I envy all the contestents, but appreciate their dedication and hardwork in producing these pics..
I have just started with Astroimaging, hence my vote goes to Strgazr27
------
Sriram
Celestron CPC 9.25 XLT
Celestron Starseeker 80mm
Homemade Dob 8"


Jon Munson
(member)
02/15/08 08:12 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

OK, I have no idea how difficult any of these shots were to obtain. I can, however, see that a great deal of work went into each. Awesome stuff folks! I really had a difficult time picking any one, so it basically came down to a "coin toss" type decision!

Ishtim
(sage)
02/15/08 09:01 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Nice work All..... I still like to see how much one can "squeeze" out of minimal equipment!!!!!

skydog
(member)
02/15/08 09:34 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Truely outstanding work all...I have to go with the sketch this time, but my goodness that was a hard decision.

tbond
(newbie)
02/15/08 11:51 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

All the pictures are awesome, cheers to all. But Jim Lafferty definately has an edge.

Adventurer
(professor emeritus)
02/16/08 02:32 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

No choice can be made, all are wonderful!
sorry


mill1599
(newbie)
02/16/08 03:19 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

They are all excellent.

My vote to Clavius Mosaic.

mill1599


RobVG
(professor emeritus)
02/16/08 03:40 PM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Did everyone get the email on the 14th

My vote would have been "Clavius".


boogie
(member)
02/17/08 04:33 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

Quote:

WOW !
What a selection trouble again...
I think that every month it gets even more difficult...

Congrats to all! Amazing work !!!




Seconded ...


stkoepke
(sage)
02/27/08 02:54 AM
Re: Jan08 CN Imaging/Sketching Contest Poll!

WOW!!!
They are all Great!!



CN Forums Home



Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics