mike bacanin
Carpal Tunnel
Reged: 03/19/07

Help needed to determine operating focal length
#5785412  04/08/13 08:11 AM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



I could do with your help in determining my operating focal length.
I have a C6,fl 1500mm. I use a 50mm long sct visual back, and into that a Baader 60 degree binoviewer with about 125mm optical path.no diagonal needed with this binoviewer. any help greatly appreciated
Thanks Mike

GlennLeDrew
Postmaster
Reged: 06/18/08
Loc: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: mike bacanin]
#5786017  04/08/13 01:21 PM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



[EDITED TO CORRECT A SLOPPY MATHEMATICAL ERROR]
It's best to measure via the star drift method. Obtain a calliper with which to measure the eyepiece field stop on something like a 2025mm Plossl, to an accuracy of 0.1mm or better. Find a star within a few degrees of the equator and time how long it takes to traverse the field, in seconds, with the drive turned off.
The field of view in degrees = drift_seconds / 239.3
The focal length = fieldstop / TAN(degrees)
Edited by GlennLeDrew (04/09/13 03:43 AM)

EdZ
Professor EdZ
Reged: 02/15/02
Loc: Cumberland, R I , USA42N71.4W

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: GlennLeDrew]
#5786360  04/08/13 04:35 PM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



Operating Focal length of C6 Plotted
edz

mike bacanin
Carpal Tunnel
Reged: 03/19/07

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: EdZ]
#5786535  04/08/13 06:04 PM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



Thank you, very helpful indeed.
Mike

GlennLeDrew
Postmaster
Reged: 06/18/08
Loc: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: mike bacanin]
#5786636  04/08/13 06:53 PM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



Due to the sensitivity of focus position on the working focal length, it still might be best to determine the value for *your* setup by actual measurement...
Then you can measure the exit pupil (to 0.05mm with a measuring loupe) in order to calculate the actual f/ratio, in order to verify if full aperture is being utilized. Alternately, you can simply magnify the exit pupil, then place a ruler, or any straight object, across the front end and locate the points which meet at the edge of the exit/entrance pupil, measuring their separation to find the working aperture.

beatlejuice
PoohBah
Reged: 04/05/11
Loc: Hamilton, ON,Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: GlennLeDrew]
#5786653  04/08/13 07:08 PM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



Quote:
The field of view in degrees = drift_seconds / 31,017,600
Glen, shouldn't that 31,017,600 be a little closer to 240?
Eric

GlennLeDrew
Postmaster
Reged: 06/18/08
Loc: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: beatlejuice]
#5787117  04/08/13 11:04 PM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



[EDITED TO FIX SLOPPY MATH...]
That big number takes into account the number of seconds in a sidereal day (86,160), times 360 degrees. The number of seconds required for an equatorial star to cross the field diameter, divided by this figure, supplies the field width in degrees.
[In edit]
That large figure is my mistake. Instead of applying 86,160 * 360 = 32 millionish, it should have been 86,160 / 360 = 239.3.
Edited by GlennLeDrew (04/09/13 03:49 AM)

beatlejuice
PoohBah
Reged: 04/05/11
Loc: Hamilton, ON,Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: GlennLeDrew]
#5787170  04/08/13 11:48 PM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



I must be missing something here. So if the drift time was 120 seconds the field width would be?
Eric
OK I get it,finally. You meant to divide 86,160 by 360 instead of multiplying, thus giving the number of seconds per degree.
Edited by beatlejuice (04/09/13 01:56 AM)

GlennLeDrew
Postmaster
Reged: 06/18/08
Loc: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: beatlejuice]
#5787333  04/09/13 03:51 AM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



Beatlejuice, You were missing nothing! I worked out the numbers and derived a correct answer when punching it in on my calculator. But I mistake you applied the wrong o

GlennLeDrew
Postmaster
Reged: 06/18/08
Loc: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: beatlejuice]
#5787334  04/09/13 03:55 AM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



Beatlejuice, You were missing nothing! I worked out the numbers and derived a correct answer when punching it in on my calculator. But I mistakenly applied the wrong operand when writing out the formula 'in my head.' I should have trusted my gut when seeing that huge number as I typed it out here.
I'm glad you persisted; your correct operand clued me in to my blunder.
Cheers!

beatlejuice
PoohBah
Reged: 04/05/11
Loc: Hamilton, ON,Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: GlennLeDrew]
#5787345  04/09/13 04:15 AM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



You sure had me scratching my head Glen because you so seldom if ever err in these matters.
BTW thanks for "The focal length = fieldstop / TAN(degrees)" I didn't know that and will put it to use soon.
Eric

GlennLeDrew
Postmaster
Reged: 06/18/08
Loc: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Re: Help needed to determine operating focal length
[Re: beatlejuice]
#5787433  04/09/13 06:09 AM

Edit

Reply

Quote 
Quick Reply



Eric, Using the tangent function is technically wrong, as it relates an angle to, well, a tangent. Angular measure on the sky, and for purposes of magnification, must work on an arc, and so is properly based on the radian. However, at small angles typical of telescopic fields, the error introduced by the tangent function is so small as to be well below the other measurement errors.
I know Jon Isaacs likes his simple (non trigbased) formula built around the figure 57.3, which is the number of degrees in one radian. I derive
TFoV = 57.3 / ( Obj. f.l. / field stop diam.)
No scientific calculator required.
