You are not logged in. [Login] Entrance · Main Index · Search · New user · Who's Online FAQ · Calendar

Equipment Discussions >> Eyepieces

Pages: 1 | 2 | (show all)
garyp1936
sage

Reged: 06/30/10

Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels
#5400358 - 09/02/12 11:18 PM

What exactly is gained by using a 1 1/4--2" combo barrel, such as a Baader Hyperion, in a 2" diagonal versus using the same EP in a 1 1/4" diagonal? I assume one gets a wider field, but how is that calculated? If one does get a wider field then the TFOV formula---AFOV/Mag---can't be used in both cases. Thanks.

 Post Extras:
nicknacknock
professor emeritus

Reged: 02/20/12

Loc: In a galaxy far far away...
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5400372 - 09/02/12 11:31 PM

No benefit in this case. Wider field comes at around 27mm as I recall. Then you need to go 2" to increase the field depending on the eyepiece type.

The only benefit to the 2" adapter is that if you have other 2" eyepieces you don't have to use the 2" to 1.25" adapter on your diagonal.

 Post Extras:
nicknacknock
professor emeritus

Reged: 02/20/12

Loc: In a galaxy far far away...
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: nicknacknock]
#5400378 - 09/02/12 11:37 PM

The formula holds, but when you want a bigger FOV than that rendered at the 27mm mark, you need to go 2" inch. Otherwise, basically the field stop steps in and you are simply not utilising the maximum FOV.

Take a Nagler 31mm for example, 82 degrees FOV on a 6" f5 refractor which has focal length of 900mm. The Nagler gives 29x magnification and TFOV of nearly 3 degrees. However, if the Nagler was 1.25' the field stop would be way below 3 degrees (bending the light through the EP elements still has to adhere to some laws of physics).

 Post Extras:
garyp1936
sage

Reged: 06/30/10

Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: nicknacknock]
#5400421 - 09/03/12 12:18 AM

I was considering a Hyperion 36mm. Again, what advantage is there in using it in a 2" diagonal rather than a 1 1/4"? Specifically, given that it has a 72 degree AFOV, what is the TFOV when used in the 2"? In the 1 1/4"? Thanks.

 Post Extras:
Jon Isaacs
Postmaster

Reged: 06/16/04

Loc: San Diego and Boulevard, CA
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5400619 - 09/03/12 06:02 AM

Quote:

I was considering a Hyperion 36mm. Again, what advantage is there in using it in a 2" diagonal rather than a 1 1/4"? Specifically, given that it has a 72 degree AFOV, what is the TFOV when used in the 2"? In the 1 1/4"? Thanks.

The Tfov depends on your scope.

In the 2 inch mode the AFoV is 72 degrees, in the 1.25 inch mode, the AFoV is about 45 degrees.

Jon

 Post Extras:
Scanning4Comets
Markus

Reged: 12/26/04

Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: Jon Isaacs]
#5400650 - 09/03/12 07:02 AM

There is one benefit when you have a 1.25" and 2" barrel eyepiece. You can use both the 2" portion and 1.25" part of the barrels to get two different magnifications in a 2" barlow lens.

The further you are away from a barlow lens, the more magnification you get.

Cheers,

 Post Extras:
Joe Ogiba
Postmaster

Reged: 02/14/02

Loc: NJ USA
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5400738 - 09/03/12 09:25 AM

You could use the 1.25" barrel in a 1.25" focuser like in binoviewers and spotting scopes then use the 2" barrel in scopes with 2" focuser. If all you have is a 1.25" focuser or 2" focuser then it has no advantage with the combo.

 Post Extras:
star drop
contra contrail

Reged: 02/02/08

Loc: Snow Plop, WNY
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: Joe Ogiba]
#5400834 - 09/03/12 10:32 AM

The manufacturer might gain a few more sales if the eyepiece has this capability.

 Post Extras:
Jon Isaacs
Postmaster

Reged: 06/16/04

Loc: San Diego and Boulevard, CA
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: Jon Isaacs]
#5400873 - 09/03/12 10:59 AM

Quote:

Quote:

I was considering a Hyperion 36mm. Again, what advantage is there in using it in a 2" diagonal rather than a 1 1/4"? Specifically, given that it has a 72 degree AFOV, what is the TFOV when used in the 2"? In the 1 1/4"? Thanks.

The Tfov depends on your scope.

In the 2 inch mode the AFoV is 72 degrees, in the 1.25 inch mode, the AFoV is about 45 degrees.

Jon

Actually the unvignetted/fully illuminated field of view would be 45 degrees, you should be able to see more but with noticeable drop off in brightness.

Jon

 Post Extras:
garyp1936
sage

Reged: 06/30/10

Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: Jon Isaacs]
#5401013 - 09/03/12 12:35 PM

Thanks. Live and learn!!! So all the 2"--1 1/4" eyepieces, such as the Hyperion and Orion's Stratus, actually have two different AFOV. The advertised 68 or 72 degree or whatever is ONLY if used in a 2" diagonal, if I understand you correctly. It would seem that it would be helpful if manufacturers would state the AFOV when using the 1 1/4" mode. Anyway, I now know something new; thanks again. Gary

 Post Extras:
edwinh
super member

Reged: 03/01/08

Loc: Chandler AZ
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5401019 - 09/03/12 12:40 PM

Not really - its only the hyperion aspherics really that do that... its really a 2" piece with a step-down. The fact that these exist make it confusing.

<24mm, 72 degree - its just convenience. Using the 24mm and down focal length hyperions in 2" or 1.25" mode makes no visual difference just a focus travel and mounting difference.

Likewise 12t4 nagler, 22panoptic, 8.8 meade uwa..... and others. a few ethoi...

 Post Extras:
garyp1936
sage

Reged: 06/30/10

Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: edwinh]
#5401040 - 09/03/12 12:54 PM

But my understanding is that there is a significant difference in focal lengths longer than 30mm. Is this correct?

 Post Extras:
csrlice12
Postmaster

Reged: 05/22/12

Loc: Denver, CO
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5401130 - 09/03/12 01:52 PM

Quote:

But my understanding is that there is a significant difference in focal lengths longer than 30mm. Is this correct?

Yes, because you have a larger field stop in a 2" vs a 1.25" eyepiece. Also, if it is a 1.25" eyepiece, with a 2" outer barrel (Think original 13mm Nagler), it is still just a 1.25" eyepiece and won't matter if you have a 1.25 or 2" focuser, you'll get the same view.

 Post Extras:
edwinh
super member

Reged: 03/01/08

Loc: Chandler AZ
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5401150 - 09/03/12 02:02 PM

Yes, for that class of AFOV eyepice, 30mm is too much for 1.25" you lose something.

But at that focal length a plossl type AFOV is just fine in 1.25":
32mm plossl, 35mm ultima.

For the 68-72deg class cut-off is about 24mm
For the 82deg type cut-off is about 17mm

Its really TFOV that is the limiter...

 Post Extras:
faackanders2
Carpal Tunnel

Reged: 03/28/11

Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5401496 - 09/03/12 05:17 PM

Benefit is it can be used in either 1.25" or 2" scopes.
2" can only be used in 2" scopes.

 Post Extras:
Jon Isaacs
Postmaster

Reged: 06/16/04

Loc: San Diego and Boulevard, CA
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5401522 - 09/03/12 05:36 PM

Quote:

Thanks. Live and learn!!! So all the 2"--1 1/4" eyepieces, such as the Hyperion and Orion's Stratus, actually have two different AFOV. The advertised 68 or 72 degree or whatever is ONLY if used in a 2" diagonal, if I understand you correctly. It would seem that it would be helpful if manufacturers would state the AFOV when using the 1 1/4" mode. Anyway, I now know something new; thanks again. Gary

Gary:

In general eyepieces that are both 2 inch and 1.25 inch are shorter focal length eyepieces with some of the optics in the 1.25 inch eyepiece barrel and this is not removed when using the 2 inch option. This means the field of view does not change when switching between the 1.25 inch and the 2 inch modes. I have several 1.25/2 inch eyepieces, the longest focal length is a 22mm Panoptic.

The 31mm and 36mm Hyperions are unusual in that you add an adapter to allow them to be used in a 1.25 inch focuser, there are probably other eyepieces setup this way but I do not know of any.

One thing to be aware of is that the field of view is determined by the diameter of the field stop. When you look through an eyepiece, the edge of the field is determined by the field stop, a ring of metal at the focal plane. With simple eyepiece like a Plossl, you can see the field stop when you look backwards down the open barrel. The larger the field stop, the larger the True Field of View.

For a 1.25 inch eyepiece, the inner diameter of the barrel is standardized at 28mm, the diameter of the filter, that is the maximum diameter possible. For a 2 inch eyepiece it's about 46mm.

One can estimate the approximate diameter of the field stop:

FS = Focal length eyepiece x AFoV (deg)/(57.3 deg/rad)

A 36mm eyepiece with a 72 degree AFoV requires a:

FS = 36mm x 72 deg/57.3 = 45mm,

So, the 36mm Hyperion has a field stop nearly the limit for a 2 inch eyepiece, it will be significantly restricted looking through a 28mm hole.

Jon

 Post Extras:
garyp1936
sage

Reged: 06/30/10

Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: Jon Isaacs]
#5401594 - 09/03/12 06:17 PM

Thanks Jon. I'll be using the formula you provided. Gary

 Post Extras:
Jon Isaacs
Postmaster

Reged: 06/16/04

Loc: San Diego and Boulevard, CA
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5401610 - 09/03/12 06:24 PM

Quote:

Thanks Jon. I'll be using the formula you provided. Gary

Gary:

It's only an approximation but reasonably accurate. Here's a scope of others, the first one is reasonably exact:

- TFoV = 57.3 deg/rad x (Field stop eyepiece)/(Focal length telescope)

- TFoV = AFoV/Mag

Jon

 Post Extras:
Gene7
scholastic sledgehammer

Reged: 06/10/10

Loc: Mid Ohio, USA
Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: Jon Isaacs]
#5415852 - 09/11/12 06:16 PM

I am just not impressed with the 36mm eyepiece, OK, but not worth the extra money over the others. I digiscope or use A-focal. A 2 inch focuser is a lot more sturdy to hang a camera attached to an eyepiece on. You do not want any sag in the focuser. Gene

 Post Extras:
Eddgie
Postmaster

Reged: 02/01/06

Re: Eyepieces with Both 1 1/4 and 2" Barrels [Re: garyp1936]
#5416052 - 09/11/12 08:10 PM

Quote:

Thanks. Live and learn!!! So all the 2"--1 1/4" eyepieces, such as the Hyperion and Orion's Stratus, actually have two different AFOV. The advertised 68 or 72 degree or whatever is ONLY if used in a 2" diagonal, if I understand you correctly. It would seem that it would be helpful if manufacturers would state the AFOV when using the 1 1/4" mode. Anyway, I now know something new; thanks again. Gary

I don't know if someone has corrected your misunderstanding of this or not..

An eyepeice won't have a difference in AFOV if it is used in a 1.25" or 2" diagonal. The diagonal has nothing to do with the apparent field of the eyepeice. That is determined by the design of the eyepeice and nothing else.

If an eyepiece is equipped with a 1.25"/2" barrel, you can use it in any diagonal and it will work exactly the same.

It is only when the field scope of the eyepiece is bigger than about 28mm that it has to be used in a 2" diagonal, but in this case, it will not be equipped with a 1.25" barrel. It will only have a 2" barrel.

So if the eyepeice has both a 1.25" and 2" barrel, it will work exactly the same whether it is used in a 1.25" or 2" focuser or diagonal.

The 1.25"/2" design is strickly a marketing design. Some amateurs want to use all 2" eyepeices and this allows that. Others want to use only 1.25" eyepeices, and that works for them as well.

It has nothing to do with the way the eyepiece actually performs with respect to AFOV or any other attribute.

 Post Extras:
Pages: 1 | 2 | (show all)

Extra information
18 registered and 37 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  ausastronomer, droid, Scott in NC

Forum Permissions
You cannot start new topics