Return to the Cloudy Nights Telescope Reviews home page

Click here if you are having trouble logging into the forums

Privacy Policy | Please read our Terms of Service | Signup and Troubleshooting FAQ | Problems? PM a Red or a Green Gu.... uh, User

Equipment Discussions >> Binoculars

ronharper
Pooh-Bah


Reged: 02/14/06
Posts: 1007
Re: Nagler-like performance...
      05/08/08 12:12 PM

Thanks for a very interesting thread. I like 7x50s and have always been curious about the Prostar.

Since somebody asked, the Fujinon 7x50 is no great shakes in this department. The field is rather curved, about 2 diopters from center to edge. Despite it's narrower apparent field, the edge is quite a bit softer than the 10x50.

Henry Link has reported in other forums that the optical train of the Prostar (and its 10x70 sibling) and FMT are very similar except the Prostar has an extra convex lens cemented to the output end of the prisms. Very interesting! Comments, BillC or Henry?

While the Prostar is apparently supreme for edge correction, it's apparent field is only 53 degrees. Several of the second-place binos provide 60-67 degrees. If these were field-stopped to 53 degrees, Ed, would it be a different story?

Ron

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Nagler-like performance... Bob Myler 05/06/08 09:28 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Joe Ogiba   05/07/08 06:19 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... ronharper   05/08/08 12:12 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/08/08 12:29 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Rich N   05/08/08 12:52 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Neil Weiner   05/08/08 01:37 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/08/08 01:39 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Rich N   05/08/08 01:44 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Rich N   05/08/08 02:17 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/08/08 01:10 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Henry Link   05/08/08 01:41 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/08/08 02:26 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Rick   05/08/08 05:36 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/08/08 07:41 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... davidmcgo   05/08/08 10:05 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Wes James   05/09/08 11:34 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/09/08 01:52 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BobinKy   05/09/08 08:44 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... DblVision   05/09/08 10:16 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/10/08 02:42 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BobinKy   05/10/08 03:21 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/10/08 10:32 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Wes James   05/10/08 10:43 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... ronharper   05/12/08 12:25 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/12/08 10:18 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Jim Rosenstock   05/12/08 10:42 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/12/08 01:23 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Wes James   05/09/08 04:13 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BobinKy   05/09/08 08:39 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/09/08 05:48 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BobinKy   05/09/08 08:26 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/09/08 07:05 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/08/08 06:11 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... StarStuff1   05/08/08 07:00 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Rich N   05/08/08 01:24 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/08/08 01:32 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Mark9473   05/06/08 03:45 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Rich N   05/06/08 03:58 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/06/08 04:28 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Bob Myler   05/06/08 06:07 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... ronharper   05/06/08 11:57 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/07/08 01:22 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Rich N   05/07/08 01:05 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/07/08 01:24 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Rich N   05/07/08 01:29 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/07/08 01:57 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/07/08 02:02 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/07/08 02:17 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Wes James   05/07/08 03:05 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/07/08 03:11 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Wes James   05/07/08 03:21 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... Wes James   05/07/08 03:11 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... EdZModerator   05/07/08 03:25 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BobinKy   05/07/08 06:27 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... John F   05/07/08 02:28 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... ausastronomer   05/07/08 05:09 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... BillC   05/07/08 01:54 AM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... gatorengineer   05/06/08 03:48 PM
. * Re: Nagler-like performance... KennyJ   05/06/08 04:05 PM

Extra information
6 registered and 14 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  EdZ 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 2983


Jump to

Home



Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics