Return to the Cloudy Nights Telescope Reviews home page

Click here if you are having trouble logging into the forums

Privacy Policy | Please read our Terms of Service | Signup and Troubleshooting FAQ | Problems? PM a Red or a Green Gu.... uh, User

Equipment Discussions >> Binoviewers

wargentin
member


Reged: 05/04/07
Posts: 16
Loc: France
Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians
      05/14/08 06:04 PM

Hello, and thank you for the comments.

Quote:

I'm curious tho- if a person were willing to create a second (*slightly* shorter) set of truss-poles for BVer mode that would accomodate focus using the OTHER glasspath correctors, the first few you mentioned- would there be an optical benefit in doing so?

I know, it'd make the Dob pretty much a "dedicated" BVer scope for that session, perhaps accompanied by a mono-scope set up adjacent? But if it would alleviate the need for the "fix" you've described, would the image quality deriving therefrom be an attractive option?




I can only speculate about this possibility. With the 1.25x and 1.7x correctors, the number of lenses would be reduced, so perhaps the contrast would be slightly enhanced. But these correctors do not suppress coma, and I don't know if they can handle a f/4 light cone without adding optical aberrations. Moreover, if the tubes are shortened, either there is a risk of vignetting by the secondary mirror, or this mirror must be slightly larger and then it increases central obstruction. Personally, it's not a solution I would choose.

Quote:

Also, at what F# would you estimate that the abberations you've described would be lessened to such a degree that *you* would consider them negligent. I know, each observer might call that at different points- yet for continuity of thot, i'm curious where *you* would mark it.




I've already asked myself this question. As a planet and lunar enthusiast, I am actually thinking about a 12" f/5 telescope. It would be less sensitive to atmospheric turbulence, it would reach thermal balance more quickly, coma would be reduced or easier to cancel, and it would nicely accept any optical accessory. For larger Dobs, which are generally limited by turbulence, I would choose f/4.5. Interestingly, I have searched some information about aberrations with fast scopes, and I have learned that SA of accessories (some eyepieces, Barlow lenses, OCS…) increases as the fourth power of 1/f# ! So an accessory can be perfect at f/5, acceptable at f/4.5, and faulty at f/4.

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians wargentin 05/12/08 09:12 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Virgogo   06/07/08 06:36 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians lni55   06/20/08 06:30 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Jeff Young   06/21/08 06:35 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Jeff Young   06/22/08 04:33 AM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians lucien   06/27/08 04:03 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Tamiji Homma   07/17/08 02:18 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Tamiji Homma   07/17/08 07:02 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians k5apl   06/25/08 02:57 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Jeff Young   06/26/08 06:36 AM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians GlennLeDrew   06/22/08 07:45 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Jan cz   06/25/08 07:26 AM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Mike B   06/25/08 12:01 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Peter Natscher   05/15/08 09:46 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Rick   05/15/08 10:30 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians gatorengineer   05/17/08 04:59 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Rick   05/13/08 05:51 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Doug D.   05/13/08 11:13 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Mike B   05/14/08 02:36 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians wargentin   05/14/08 06:04 PM
. * Re: Baader Mark V and fast Newtonians Mike B   05/14/08 06:44 PM

Extra information
0 registered and 2 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  EdZ, jrcrilly 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 1515


Jump to

Home



Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics