Return to the Cloudy Nights Telescope Reviews home page

Click here if you are having trouble logging into the forums

Privacy Policy | Please read our Terms of Service | Signup and Troubleshooting FAQ | Problems? PM a Red or a Green Gu.... uh, User

Equipment Discussions >> ATM, Optics and DIY Forum

DAVIDG
Pooh-Bah
*****

Reged: 12/02/04
Posts: 1446
Loc: Hockessin, De
Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces
      07/02/08 09:38 AM

If you want the "best" telescope, it should be unobstructed for the highest possible contrast. Have a f-ratio of 8 or greater, so it does cause problems with the choice of an eyepieces. Have the least amount of surfaces. Have surfaces that are spherical for easy testing to achieve a perfect null. Be diffraction limited over 1/4 degree of view and have flat or nearly flat focal plane.

Given the above one should consider a Schiefspiegler, since the two mirror design can use two mirrors of equal radius and spherical surfaces. Just a bit more difficult to make then a standard newtonian, since the tool for the mirror becomes the secondary. In my opinion it's easier since all the surfaces are spherical and you can easily test for a null. Plus it is unobstructed system which is critical for the achieving the highest contrast.
Then there is a Schupmann medial refractor which is made from two pieces of the inexpensive BK-7 crown glass, and is perfectly color corrected, much better then a APO. It also has a version with all spherical surfaces. Has very close to a perfect MTF curve for ultra high contrast. It can be diffraction limited for all colors over 1/2 degree field of view and of course is unobstructed.

- Dave

--------------------
Homemade 'scopes 8"f/7,6" f/5", 6"f/4, 4.25" Schief. 60mm Coronagraph,60mm H-alpha system, 4.25" White-light Solar Newtonian,solar spectroscope, 4.5" f/16 Schupmann Medial refractor, 14 Stellafane awards 7 in optics

Engineering = Taking what you have and making what you need.

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy 06/30/08 03:47 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/05/08 04:57 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces nytecam   07/02/08 02:23 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/02/08 05:29 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/03/08 01:16 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Starkler   07/04/08 11:22 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/04/08 02:14 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/04/08 06:15 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/03/08 07:12 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces jpcannavo   07/03/08 07:36 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/03/08 07:36 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/03/08 08:14 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/02/08 01:32 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/02/08 05:23 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/03/08 01:03 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/03/08 07:01 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Don WModerator   06/30/08 04:02 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   06/30/08 04:26 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Biff   06/30/08 08:29 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces wallie x   07/05/08 04:35 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/05/08 11:18 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/08/08 01:11 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces DAVIDG   07/08/08 02:42 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/08/08 04:11 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces DAVIDG   07/09/08 12:03 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/10/08 06:02 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces DAVIDG   07/10/08 07:45 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/13/08 06:40 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/14/08 01:29 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces sixela   07/14/08 08:47 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/14/08 01:21 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/15/08 11:11 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/15/08 12:35 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces sixela   07/15/08 05:21 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Owen   07/16/08 04:45 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces sixela   07/16/08 06:17 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Owen   07/16/08 06:55 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces sixela   07/16/08 07:03 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/16/08 07:15 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/22/08 03:42 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/14/08 08:36 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces sixela   07/14/08 09:39 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Almagne   07/09/08 12:51 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces DAVIDG   07/09/08 03:15 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/02/08 05:21 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HiggsBoson   07/01/08 12:54 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Houdini   07/01/08 07:31 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/02/08 05:30 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces DAVIDG   07/02/08 09:38 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/03/08 06:58 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/03/08 01:30 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/03/08 07:30 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Fiske   07/03/08 07:37 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/03/08 05:14 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Fiske   07/04/08 12:21 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Fiske   07/04/08 12:25 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Chriske   07/03/08 08:02 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/05/08 04:33 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces DAVIDG   07/05/08 10:20 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/05/08 11:45 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces DAVIDG   07/05/08 01:13 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces HandyAndy   07/06/08 08:44 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces DAVIDG   07/06/08 10:54 AM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces mark cowan   07/03/08 05:18 PM
. * Re: The 'Best' telescope and eyepieces Chriske   07/02/08 09:50 AM

Extra information
14 registered and 9 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Don W, Joe Cipriano 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 1628


Jump to

Home



Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics