Return to the Cloudy Nights Telescope Reviews home page

Click here if you are having trouble logging into the forums

Privacy Policy | Please read our Terms of Service | Signup and Troubleshooting FAQ | Problems? PM a Red or a Green Gu.... uh, User

Other >> Science of Astronomy & Space exploration

Dane B
super member


Reged: 02/23/08
Posts: 120
Loc: Seattle, Wa
Re: What drives an atom?
      07/11/08 06:17 PM

That's not a silly question at all!

I once asked a physical chemist a similar question - "what prevents an electron from falling into the nucleus". Because I had only minimal education in quantum mechanics he couldn't give me a direct answer, but what I took away from the conversation is that the question is flawed. While we can measure properties of the electron and get either a position or a velocity or an uncertain combination of both, the wavefunction that actually describes the properties of the electron do not yield specific locations or velocities and so it is incorrect to think of an electron as moving along a definite path.

Perhaps it is incorrect to think of the electron as moving at all. It exists in a superposition of states, and upon measuring we get information about one of those states, but that doesn't describe the electron in general.

Hopefully someone here can provide a more definitive answer...

--------------------
Meade DS-2130AT w/ GOTO
Nikon 12x50AEs


Without judgement what would we do? We would be forced to look at ourselves...

-Death

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* What drives an atom? Taqyon 07/11/08 05:07 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? deSitter   07/22/08 09:19 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/24/08 07:42 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/13/08 01:14 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/13/08 11:37 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/11/08 06:17 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/11/08 06:38 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Joad   07/11/08 09:33 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? stefsaber   07/12/08 10:21 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/12/08 06:36 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? stefsaber   07/12/08 09:19 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? jupiterzkool   07/12/08 10:02 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? UWastronomer   07/12/08 10:24 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/13/08 08:02 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/13/08 11:11 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/14/08 06:13 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/15/08 01:43 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/15/08 05:44 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/15/08 10:14 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/17/08 07:10 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/15/08 10:35 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/16/08 06:05 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/16/08 11:56 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/17/08 06:50 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/17/08 10:13 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? jayscheuerle   07/15/08 03:32 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/16/08 10:39 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/17/08 07:14 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/17/08 11:04 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? llanitedaveModerator   07/17/08 02:58 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Joad   07/17/08 11:28 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/18/08 12:21 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/18/08 12:43 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/17/08 11:19 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/17/08 10:04 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/18/08 07:43 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/18/08 11:20 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/19/08 06:19 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? jupiterzkool   07/19/08 05:54 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/24/08 07:37 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/19/08 08:01 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/19/08 01:30 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/26/08 07:24 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/28/08 05:31 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   07/28/08 08:52 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   08/04/08 07:20 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Qkslvr   07/28/08 10:30 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? nimthor   07/26/08 09:58 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? star drop   07/27/08 01:58 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/28/08 02:33 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Qkslvr   07/28/08 10:11 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Dane B   08/04/08 09:13 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   08/04/08 10:12 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? llanitedaveModerator   08/04/08 10:38 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Qkslvr   08/05/08 12:55 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Taqyon   07/24/08 07:36 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/17/08 05:39 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? stefsaber   07/13/08 12:06 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? astrotrf   07/21/08 07:19 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? HiggsBoson   07/22/08 01:51 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? astrotrf   07/22/08 01:40 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/24/08 10:56 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Qkslvr   07/25/08 11:51 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/25/08 12:38 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Qkslvr   07/25/08 01:30 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/25/08 02:06 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Qkslvr   07/25/08 02:33 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? llanitedaveModerator   07/26/08 03:47 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Pess   07/29/08 01:58 PM
. * Re: What drives an atom? Qkslvr   07/28/08 10:24 AM
. * Re: What drives an atom? llanitedaveModerator   07/11/08 11:52 PM

Extra information
2 registered and 2 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  llanitedave 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 1546


Jump to

Home



Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics