Return to the Cloudy Nights Telescope Reviews home page

Click here if you are having trouble logging into the forums

Privacy Policy | Please read our Terms of Service | Signup and Troubleshooting FAQ | Problems? PM a Red or a Green Gu.... uh, User

Equipment Discussions >> Refractors

dothead
super member


Reged: 08/13/08
Posts: 163
Loc: Heidelberg, Germany
Re: FET-300/EM-3700
      08/14/08 07:28 PM

Daniel,

Interesting you mention Pons' scope. Maybe a Petzval type refractor would be the way to go to avoid thermal problems caused by too much glass (too many elements) in one place.
By the way, Daniel, have you ever heard of the 10 inch Petzval (2 front, 3 rear elements) APO made by the Colorado based EQUINOX INTERSCIENCE company (you can google their website). Looks like a truly professional scope (for instance, it sports an 8 inch focuser!); with a $90000 price tag for the OTA alone, it's certainly out of reach for all but the most affluent amateurs (talk about a dream scope!).
My dream refractor would be a 20 inch F/30 folded D&G achromat. To mount this thing, a AP El Capitan mount would surely be way too small! But Markus Ludes of APM Telescopes sells an equatorial mount which weighs 1000 lbs without counterweights (for Euro 24000) which should handle the OTA.
Together with a Zeiss 160 mm eyepiece (70 degres AFOV, 180 mm field stop, 8 inch barrel), which Markus also had on offer for quite some time (sold now), you could attain a TFOV of 41 arc minutes, despite the 600 inch focal length of the 20 inch - F/30 D&G. The color correction of this scope should be roughly equivalent to an 6 inch F/9 achromat (devide the f-ratio by the aperture (in this case, 30/20 or 9/6 and get 1,5. The old rule is that once you get over 5, achromats reach apochromatic colour correction. For instance, an 3 inch F/15 achromat (yes, the old Tascos! (Royal company objective lens) show almost no residual colour even at a magnification of 50x per inch)).

Cheers,

Ralph

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* FET-300/EM-3700 Tamiji Homma 08/12/08 10:54 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 art1942us   08/21/08 11:08 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Mike Clemens   08/21/08 01:25 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Tomvictor   08/13/08 10:48 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 roadi   08/12/08 11:36 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 SkyscraperJim   08/12/08 12:45 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 ABC   08/15/08 03:29 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 ValeryD   08/16/08 12:53 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/16/08 09:29 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 lukman   08/16/08 10:23 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 leexeen   08/16/08 10:05 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/16/08 11:24 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 EricCCD   08/21/08 01:26 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/21/08 06:35 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 lukman   08/16/08 08:23 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Erik Bakker   08/16/08 11:49 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 leexeen   08/16/08 12:10 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 lukman   08/16/08 08:29 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 dothead   08/15/08 08:27 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/15/08 09:13 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 jouster   08/15/08 08:19 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/15/08 09:19 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 dothead   08/15/08 11:45 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/15/08 03:52 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 dothead   08/15/08 04:35 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/15/08 08:02 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 dothead   08/15/08 08:30 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 lukman   08/15/08 08:44 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/15/08 08:47 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 lukman   08/15/08 08:58 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 ABC   08/15/08 09:32 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 ABC   08/15/08 09:06 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 dothead   08/15/08 08:08 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Daniel Mounsey   08/12/08 11:21 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Daniel Mounsey   08/12/08 11:25 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 dothead   08/14/08 07:28 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/14/08 08:01 PM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 dothead   08/15/08 12:05 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 Dave Novoselsky   08/15/08 09:08 AM
. * Re: FET-300/EM-3700 jdownie   08/12/08 11:12 AM

Extra information
33 registered and 16 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  desertstars, Remy Bosio, Jason B, LLEEGE 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 1812


Jump to

CN Forums Home



Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics