Return to the Cloudy Nights Telescope Reviews home page
   · Get a Cloudy Nights T-Shirt · Submit a Review / Article   

Click here if you are having trouble logging into the forums

Privacy Policy | Please read our Terms of Service | Signup and Troubleshooting FAQ | Problems? PM a Red or a Green Gu.... uh, User

Equipment Discussions >> Binoculars

BobinKy
Carpal Tunnel
*****

Reged: 04/27/07
Posts: 1683
Re: ED glass in binoculars
      07/02/09 09:11 AM

EdZ...

How right you are. I posted the previous link because of its diversity of opinions about the ED/nonED versions of a specific model. I think discussion and different opinions make online forums worth the time and effort to participate and keep up with the topics.

. . .

Now, regarding the ED/nonED question, I think we cannot really do the topic justice without entering the discussion of color sensitivity among various observers. Simply put, how much do differences of color sensitivity by individual observers affect the decision to purchase an ED or nonED model? If the observer's eyes are sensitive to one or more colors, maybe the ED binocular may be worth the premium price. On the other hand, if the observer has limited sensitivity to colors, the nonED binocular may see just as much as the ED model.

EdZ, I know you discussed color sensitivity differences among observers. However, here is a link from another forum with links to medical research that also discuss the many nuances of color sensitivity. I direct any interested reader to the links in my first post of the thread in the link below--
    (1) How we see colors
    (2) Intertwining of color sensitivity with the other senses
    (3) Possible gender differences in color sensitivity.
Here is the link: What determines our color sensitivity as looking through bins? .

The link also discusses brand manufacturer bias toward specific colors, as well as atmospheric influences upon brand manufacturer's color rendering. Some of the participants in the link have actually done tests (with photos) of brand manufacturing bias.

--------------------
Bob
38°N


Edited by BobinKy (07/03/09 08:00 AM)

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* ED glass in binoculars EdZ 07/01/09 02:51 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars milt   07/01/09 09:03 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars ronharper   07/02/09 12:59 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/02/09 05:45 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Gordon Rayner   07/02/09 04:31 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars NDfarmer   07/02/09 07:43 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Mr. Bill   07/02/09 01:52 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars BobinKy   07/02/09 07:38 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars BobinKy   07/02/09 08:25 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/02/09 08:38 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars BobinKy   07/02/09 09:11 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/02/09 09:26 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars gmazza   07/02/09 10:21 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars ronharper   07/02/09 10:35 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars gmazza   07/02/09 11:06 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars BillC   07/02/09 12:12 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Wes James   07/02/09 02:28 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars KennyJ   07/02/09 12:32 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Pinewood   07/02/09 01:36 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars *DELETED* BobinKy   07/02/09 10:10 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars BobinKy   07/02/09 11:38 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Andresin150   07/03/09 02:14 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars FrankKD   07/08/09 09:46 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/08/09 02:30 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars milt   07/08/09 03:13 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/08/09 03:32 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars milt   07/08/09 06:06 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/08/09 07:02 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars milt   07/08/09 07:08 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/10/09 04:25 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars gmazza   07/08/09 05:18 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars mooreorless   07/02/09 07:48 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars gmazza   07/02/09 08:18 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/02/09 08:22 AM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Wes James   07/01/09 03:32 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars brocknroller   07/01/09 08:13 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Pinewood   07/02/09 03:54 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars brocknroller   07/02/09 07:43 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars moynihan   07/02/09 02:32 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars BobinKy   07/01/09 08:31 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars KennyJ   07/01/09 04:11 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars EdZModerator   07/01/09 04:46 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Man in a Tub   07/01/09 05:32 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars GlenM   07/01/09 05:50 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars gmazza   07/01/09 06:21 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars daniel_h   07/01/09 06:58 PM
. * Re: ED glass in binoculars Mr. Bill   07/01/09 07:40 PM

Extra information
3 registered and 16 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  EdZ 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 1603


Jump to

CN Forums Home



Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics