Return to the Cloudy Nights Telescope Reviews home page
   · Get a Cloudy Nights T-Shirt · Submit a Review / Article   

Click here if you are having trouble logging into the forums

Privacy Policy | Please read our Terms of Service | Signup and Troubleshooting FAQ | Problems? PM a Red or a Green Gu.... uh, User

Equipment Discussions >> Refractors

peleuba
sage


Reged: 12/01/04
Posts: 326
Loc: Southern PA
Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet
      11/04/09 01:31 PM Attachment (30 downloads)

Quote:

Yeah, you’re right. I thought that OK4’s Abbe number was in the low 80’s but it is actually 92.05 making it very close to FPL-53! So after some quick number crunching pitted with some guestimation I would say that these 152mm f/8 doublets should be only slightly on the high side of being color free. I would suspect that some color will be visible, especially at higher powers, but the color should be very well suppressed (I’m guessing at about 33% to 50% better than the Meade 152ED).




To put this thread in perspective I think the new lens would be equivalent to a 6" Fluorite doublet which will have noticeable color. depending on mating element and any touch-up, it could be slightly better or slightly worse. But definitely in the neighborhood.

Below is a star test image from the bench on a TAK FS152 that I used to own. Lots of color. But at precise focus the image was excellent, just slightly warm looking. The 1/6 wave of Astig is not seen when the scope is in the field pointing up - its an artifact of the test stand.

--------------------
Paul Leuba

TEC160FL #025
StarMaster 14.5 goto/track
Portaball-8
Canon 10X30 IS Binocs
Sets of Nagler T4's, T5's, T6's, TAK LE's, TV Plossls

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog 10/10/09 09:51 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet revans   10/12/09 08:22 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet KerryR   10/10/09 04:30 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Darren Bly   10/10/09 12:41 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet alfi1966   10/10/09 01:02 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Darren Bly   10/10/09 02:52 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Don Allen   10/10/09 03:30 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog   10/10/09 03:29 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet old_frankland   10/10/09 03:59 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Scott99   10/10/09 12:06 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Doug76   10/10/09 10:39 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog   10/10/09 11:48 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Doug76   10/10/09 06:23 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Jeff B   10/10/09 10:10 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog   10/10/09 10:20 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet APM M.Ludes   10/11/09 10:19 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Don Allen   10/11/09 09:53 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Patricko   10/12/09 11:09 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet jayscheuerle   10/12/09 09:35 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Texas   10/13/09 07:27 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Don Allen   10/13/09 08:11 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Texas   10/13/09 09:20 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet alfi1966   10/13/09 08:26 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet johnnyha   10/13/09 07:52 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet alfi1966   10/13/09 08:05 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Gaz O'C   10/13/09 03:52 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet snart   10/13/09 04:51 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Doug76   10/13/09 04:59 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet snart   10/12/09 10:29 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet irons   02/16/10 01:14 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog   10/12/09 11:36 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet snart   10/12/09 01:11 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet peleuba   11/04/09 01:31 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Clive Gibbons   11/04/09 03:26 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet deSitter   11/05/09 02:47 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet KerryR   10/12/09 11:53 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Don Allen   10/12/09 12:21 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet pollux   10/12/09 12:28 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Don Allen   10/12/09 01:44 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Doug76   10/12/09 02:17 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Bill Cowles   10/12/09 10:54 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Clive Gibbons   10/12/09 05:41 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet skyjim   10/12/09 09:16 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Don Allen   10/12/09 11:05 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet jrcrillyAdministrator   10/12/09 11:23 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Doug76   10/13/09 12:35 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet APM M.Ludes   10/13/09 10:38 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet astrokwang2   10/13/09 09:27 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet prova   10/14/09 12:09 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet alfi1966   10/14/09 10:40 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Clive Gibbons   10/14/09 11:19 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog   10/13/09 10:50 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet KerryR   10/13/09 11:16 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Jeff B   10/13/09 09:25 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet KerryR   10/14/09 11:10 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet ValeryD   10/13/09 05:50 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet KerryR   10/14/09 11:22 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet alfi1966   10/14/09 11:32 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet APM M.Ludes   10/15/09 10:02 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet alan_nasu   11/04/09 01:37 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet APM M.Ludes   11/04/09 03:19 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet snart   11/05/09 03:15 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Doug76   10/15/09 10:24 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet snart   10/13/09 12:53 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Don Allen   10/13/09 02:28 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet RodgerHouTex   10/13/09 03:11 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog   10/13/09 04:25 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet CESDewar   10/13/09 08:56 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet BluewaterObserva   10/13/09 04:41 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Doug76   10/12/09 07:01 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Patricko   10/12/09 08:10 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog   10/12/09 09:14 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Jeff B   10/12/09 03:50 PM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Patricko   10/12/09 11:01 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet AlienRatDog   10/12/09 08:14 AM
. * Re: 6" f/8 ED doublet Doug76   10/11/09 10:19 PM

Extra information
32 registered and 21 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  desertstars, Jason B, LLEEGE 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 2747


Jump to

CN Forums Home


Cloudy Nights LLC
Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics