Return to the Cloudy Nights Telescope Reviews home page

Click here if you are having trouble logging into the forums

Privacy Policy | Please read our Terms of Service | Signup and Troubleshooting FAQ | Problems? PM a Red or a Green Gu.... uh, User

Equipment Discussions >> Binoculars

patter1
professor emeritus


Reged: 01/19/05
Posts: 597
Loc: Canada
Re: Does aperture rule in bino land?
      12/07/05 04:08 PM

So is there agreement that while keeping magnification constant you'll never see less with larger apertures, but depending on the extent of light pollution, the gain by a larger aperture might be far less than what one might expect? This sounds right.

It's just that on these boards, you'll often hear repeated over and over: "big exit pupils are bad under light pollution - smaller exit pupils will give more contrast" - without any qualifications - as if to imply that you'll see more contrast, more stars, by simply reducing the aperture of an instrument...which is untrue regardless of the amount of light pullution.

Rather it should be: "for a given aperture, you'll often see more at higher magnifications despite the smaller exit pupil, not because of it."

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Does aperture rule in bino land? jake47 12/06/05 01:42 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? jake47   12/06/05 11:28 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 08:35 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Mike Harvey   12/06/05 02:10 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Erik D   12/06/05 03:57 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? CESDewar   12/07/05 11:04 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/06/05 03:24 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? KennyJ   12/06/05 03:31 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/06/05 01:52 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? edcannon   12/06/05 04:53 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/06/05 07:43 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? patter1   12/07/05 09:44 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/07/05 10:07 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? *DELETED* BluewaterObserva   12/07/05 10:36 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? sjs42   12/10/05 12:19 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? KennyJ   12/08/05 02:56 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? patter1   12/08/05 03:43 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? KennyJ   12/08/05 03:54 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/08/05 04:34 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? milt   12/08/05 09:16 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/09/05 08:45 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/07/05 11:10 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? *DELETED* BluewaterObserva   12/07/05 11:14 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 11:23 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? *DELETED* BluewaterObserva   12/07/05 11:32 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 11:52 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/07/05 12:15 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? *DELETED* BluewaterObserva   12/07/05 12:19 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Glassthrower   12/07/05 12:45 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 01:03 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? *DELETED* BluewaterObserva   12/07/05 01:10 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 01:34 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? patter1   12/07/05 04:08 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/07/05 05:03 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? DJB   12/08/05 03:29 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 05:56 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Mark9473   12/07/05 04:14 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/07/05 12:35 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? *DELETED* BluewaterObserva   12/07/05 12:45 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/07/05 01:13 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 11:08 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 08:30 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Glassthrower   12/06/05 07:55 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/07/05 08:27 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? DJB   12/07/05 03:03 AM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? EdZModerator   12/06/05 08:22 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? edwincjones   12/06/05 09:23 PM
. * Re: Does aperture rule in bino land? Anonymous   12/06/05 07:25 PM

Extra information
5 registered and 18 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  EdZ 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 1468


Jump to

Home



Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics