Quote:

---

It might be a little more general to say that the reason broader "nebula" H-alpha filters won't show the chromospheric detail is that they are letting in a little too much off-band light from the photosphere. That light is basically "drowning out" the weaker chromosphere... With a regular white-light solar filter, you would, of course, dim the chromospheric emission, but the H-alpha filter would still be letting in too much light from wavelengths well away from the H-alpha centerline, and that is the crux of the problem.

---

The off-band contamination of a broad-band H alpha nebula filter used with a white light filter is irrelevant and only adds insult to injury: chromospheric details and prominences will be invisible with a white light filter because they are rendered 100,000 to 1,000,000 times fainter than they otherwise would be. That's why during the totality phase of a solar eclipse you do not see anything through a telescope equiped with a white light filter, where there is no side band contamination whatsoever.

This is easy to verify, since a narrow-band H alpha filter passes ~ 95% + of the H alpha emission -- just place a white light filter in front of your PST or other H alpha solar filtered telescope -- there will be no image to observe, even without photosphereic side band contamination.

--------------------
Bob Yoesle

You are a child of the universe,
no less than the trees and the stars...
And whether or not it is clear to you,
no doubt the universe is unfolding as it should.

Desiderata

Post Extras