
Cosmic Challenge: Hickson Compact Galaxy Group 44
Discuss this article in our forums
|
Cosmic Challenge: Hickson Compact Galaxy Group 44
|
Target |
Type |
RA |
DEC |
Const. |
Mag. |
Size |
Hickson
Compact |
Galaxy |
10h 39.2m |
+21° 49.3' |
Leo |
various |
16' |
In 1982, astronomer Paul Hickson, professor of astronomy at the University of British Columbia , published a study of 100 compact galaxy groups scattered throughout the sky. In his paper "Systematic Properties of Compact Groups of Galaxies", Hickson defined a compact galaxy group as a small, relatively isolated collection of four or five individual systems that are set in close proximity to one another, and that differ in brightness by no more than 3 magnitudes. Further, so as to avoid including the central regions of dense galaxy clusters, Hickson stipulated an "isolation factor" requiring that there not be a non-member galaxy of similar magnitude within three radii of the group's center.
|
Above: Evening star map showing the location of this month's Cosmic Challenge. Credit: Map adapted from Star Watch by Phil Harrington
|
Above: Finder chart for this month's Cosmic Challenge.
Credit: Chart adapted from Cosmic Challenge by Phil Harrington
|
Surveying the Palomar Observatory Sky Survey, Hickson created an inventory of 100 such groupings. The entries in the Hickson Compact Group, or HCG, catalog are ordered numerically according to increasing right ascension. The classic example of a compact galaxy group, and the first of the genre to be discovered, is Stephan's Quintet in Pegasus (October 2017 Cosmic Challenge), which Hickson cross-referenced as HCG 92.
Stephan's Quintet is probably the best-known example of a compact galaxy group, but it is by no means the brightest. That honor falls to HCG 44, nicknamed the Leo Quartet. HCG 44, itemized in the table below, is easily pinpointed a little less than halfway between the stars Adhafera [Zeta (ζ) Leonis] and Algieba [Gamma (γ) Leonis] along the sickle of Leo the Lion. If you center your finderscope on Adhafera (Zeta), you will see 6th-magnitude 39 Leonis just 20' to its south-southeast. Without moving the aim, look for two 7.6-magnitude stars closer to the southern edge of the finder field. See them? Good.
Members of Hickson Compact Group 44
Object |
RA |
Dec |
Magnitude |
Size |
NGC 3185 |
10 17.6 |
+21 41.3 |
12.2 |
2.3'x1.5' |
NGC 3187 |
10 17.8 |
+21 52.4 |
13.4 |
3.6'x1.6' |
NGC 3190 |
10 18.1 |
+21 50.0 |
11.1 |
4.4'x1.2' |
NGC 3193 |
10 18.3 |
+21 53.6 |
10.9 |
2.0'x2.0' |
Recenter your telescope on the western star in that pair, listed as SAO 81276 (aka HD 89224), insert a medium-power eyepiece, and take a look just to its south. Two faint blurs should be immediately visible. The smaller and easternmost of the two blurs is NGC 3193, found just 1' to the south of 9th-magnitude SAO 81279. My 10-inch scope at 106x reveals this E2 elliptical as a bright, round glow highlighted by a brighter core.
NGC 3193 plays second fiddle to the group's brightest member, the edge-on spiral NGC 3190. Its cigar-shaped disk appears elongated northwest-to-southeast and surrounds a faint stellar nucleus. Photographs reveal that, like many edge-on spirals, NGC 3190 is bisected by a lane of opaque dust that runs along its galactic plane south of the central core. I have failed to see the lane through my 10-inch under suburban skies, but others report success under darker conditions with the same aperture. Larger instruments show that the dark lane's western tip appears to curl northward slightly due to the tug of an external gravitation source.
|
Above: Digitized sketch of HCG 44 through the author's 10-inch (25-cm) reflector.
Below: HCG 44, as captured by the author's 6-inch (15-cm) Celestron Origin Home Observatory. North is toward the upper right corner. Click here for a full size image and exposure details on the author's Astrobin page.
|
|
That source of gravity is most likely NGC 3187, a dim barred spiral just 5' to the northwest. Shining at magnitude 13.4 and spanning some 4'x2', NGC 3187 is the faintest of the group. Its inherent low surface brightness is easily overwhelmed by the light of nearby HD 89224, our finder star 6' to the northeast. Move the star out of the field and the galaxy's faint glow should pop into view with averted vision. Look for a dim, featureless smudge of grayish light that is oriented parallel to NGC 3190 and just 1' north of two 14th-magnitude field stars. Large instruments will also show two faint extensions of NGC 3187's spiral disk. The western end curls northward, while the eastern tip curls southward, forming a unique S-shape.
The final member of the four, NGC 3185. To find it, hop south from NGC 3190 to a pair of 10th-magnitude stars. Together with three similarly bright stars to their east, they form a distended "M". Look 5' due west of the southernmost star in the pair for NGC 3185.Its diffuse glow draws to a slightly brighter core and appears extended slightly northwest-southeast. With averted vision, the southwestern edge of the galaxy appears to just kiss a 14th-magnitude field star. That star is well within the Milky Way, however, so dont mistake it for an extragalactic supernova.
Larger apertures may also spot PGC 86788, is a dwarf spiral galaxy about 100 million light-years away. It appears isolated but might still be gravitationally linked to HCG 44.
Another galactic photobomber, PGC 2806871 is a faint dwarf spiral galaxy at around 250 million light years from the Milky Way. It has no physical association with the galaxy group.
Have a favorite challenge object of your own? I'd love to hear about it, as well as how you did with this month's challenge. Contact me through my website or post to this month's discussion forum.
Remember that half of the fun is the thrill of the chase. Game on!
|
About
the Author: |
Phil Harrington's Cosmic Challenge is copyright 2025 by Philip S. Harrington. All rights reserved. No reproduction, in whole or in part, beyond single copies for use by an individual, is permitted without written permission of the copyright holder. |
- John O'Hara, Procyon, Sasa and 2 others like this
10 Comments
Under a dark sky, I've seen NGC 3190 and 3193 in my 63mm refractor, using 53x and 84x. The other two are not visible. NGC 3185 was visible with effort in my old 4.5" f/8 Newtonian at 50x. NGC 3187 took a 12" Dobsonian to see.
I plan to take a photo of Hickson 44 with my Zeiss Meniscas 150 and smartphone, when I get the chance. I'll also take a look visually with my 6" Dobsonian.
Clear skies!
Thomas, Denmark
I have seen only three galaxies so far. The best view was through 110mm refractor from my (former) darker sky observatory. The brightest member, NGC3190 was even showing some detail: oval shape, right rounded core from which there were two brighter lines going along the major axis. NGC3193 was a round glow with strong central condensation and stellar nucleus. There were no detail in case of NGC3185, just faint rounded glow without any significant central condensation. After a while, it became quite well visible with averted vision. Here is the sketch from that night:
I managed to take a mediocre image of Hickson 44 on the evening of March 6th, in bright moonlight, using my smartphone and Zeiss Meniscas 150/2250mm Maksutov.
Visually, I could see NGC 3190 quite easily through the Meniscas at 70x (32mm Masuyama 85°), with NGC 3193 being dimly visible as a round glow. The other two weren't visible on this evening.
The image isn't much to look at, but here it is. I had to crop it quite severely, to get rid of some ugly gradients. Flats failed to correct for the vignetting, for some reason.
Hickson 44 galaxy cluster, March 6th, 2025. Zeiss Meniscas 150/2250, 40mm GSO projection eyepiece, 56x. 56 x 30 seconds, 6400ISO. OnePlus Nord CE3 Lite smartphone, Deep Sky Camera app. Stacked in DSS, processed in Windows Pictures. Crop of a larger field.
Clear skies!
Thomas, Denmark
I had viewed Hickson 44 from pristine Arizona skies with a 24" Dob and 16" SCT. All four galaxies were immediately evident with magnifications of 277x (24") and 200x (16"). I was curious as to how they would look from the Midwest skies of western Kentucky where I now reside. In the 16" SCT, NGC 3190 and NGC 3193 stood out, with NGC 3185 more subtle but visible at 100x and 145x. Increasing magnification to 270x gave the best view of NGC 3187. My visual impression was similar to the detail in Astrojensen's image in the preceding post.
I've been experimenting with focal reducers on my f/11 C14. I found that with lenses installed at both positions in a Giant Easy Guider (plus a little additional spacing), I could get the focal ratio down to f/3.6, primarily to give a larger field of view for my OSC camera. Hickson 44 seemed like an excellent subject. Here is a cropped image that is a little rough - still some artifacts - but the group shows up well. PGC 2806871 is also visible. PGC 86788 is a "maybe" smudge. North is up. 90 x 20sec unguided subs for a total of 30 minutes. I also noted all four NGC galaxies showed up on single 60 second exposures.
I've observed Hickson 44 many times with a variety of telescopes. It's my favorite Hickson group.
Here's a 43-minute-long-exposure of Hickson 44 that I captured with my Seestar S50 tonight from my red zone home. It's been Seestar S50 AI denoised and enhanced a bit using Photoshop. I got a high SQM-L reading of 18.91 mpsas.
Attached Thumbnails
This is a cropped version of the above Seestar S50 image.
Attached Thumbnails
I acquired this image of three of the galaxies in Hickson 44 in 2013 using what was then known as the Bradford Robotic Telescope, a Celestron C14 SCT situated on Tenerife in the Canary Islands.
Attached Thumbnails
I imaged Hickson 44 again this morning from the orange zone Naylor Observatory.
Attached Thumbnails
Here's an AI denoised version.
Attached Thumbnails