Jump to content

  •  

- - - - -

Cosmic Challenge: M13's propeller


Discuss this article in our forums

Cosmic Challenge: M13's propeller

July 2017

Phil Harrington

This month's suggested aperture range

10- to 14-inch (25-36 cm) scopes

Target

Type

RA

DEC

Constellation

Magnitude

Size

M13's propeller

Globular cluster

16 41.7

+36 27.6

Hercules

5.8

20'


In last month's column, we paid a visit to the Moon and the crater pair of Messier and Messier A.  This month, we head back out into deep space to examine one of the most spectacular entries in Charles Messier's catalog: M13, the Great Hercules Globular Cluster.

Above: Summer star map from Star Watch by Phil Harrington.

 

Above: Finder chart for this month's Cosmic Challenge.

Chart adapted from Cosmic Challenge by Phil Harrington.
Click on the chart to open a printable PDF version in a new window.

There are few deep-sky objects more spectacular through a large telescope than globular clusters. Each globular cluster may contain hundreds of thousands to several million stars, all swarming together around a core so densely packed that seeing individual points may defy resolution. But the view is spectacular nonetheless.

To the casual eye, all globular clusters may look the same. Just a big ball of stars, right? Nothing could be further from the truth. Each has a personality all its own, often with hidden treasures lying within, if you take the time to look.

M13, the grand globular cluster in mighty Hercules, is the perfect example. It doesn't take a double-digit aperture to see that the stars of M13 are distributed asymmetrically. An 8-inch (20cm), and even smaller instruments, will show how the stars appear to be arranged into curves or rows. Many have likened the cluster's appearance to that of a spider. John Herschel described the cluster as exhibiting "hairy-looking, curvilinear branches." Later, Lord Rosse saw M13 as "more distinctly separated and brighter than anticipated; singularly fringed appendages to the globular figure branching out into the surrounding space."

Observing notes made while I was viewing through my 10-inch telescope at 58x recall irregular strings of stars streaming out from the cluster's dense core. Two thin threads curving away toward the west strike me as particularly conspicuous. These star-strings give the impression that M13 is hurtling through space so quickly that is it leaving a trail of stars behind in its wake.

Increasing the 10-inch's magnification to 181x reveals a surprise that goes unsuspected at lower values. The star streamers are still evident, but hidden within the core, southeast of the exact center, are three subtle dark lanes that seemingly join together to form the letter "Y." The combined effect is nicknamed the M13 propeller.

Above: A sketch of M13 and its propeller through my 10-inch (25cm) Newtonian.


These unusual lanes, or propeller as many call them, were first discovered by Bindon Stoney in about 1850. At the time, Stoney was an astronomer working for Lord Rosse at Birr Castle in Parsontown, Ireland. After Stoney's initial sighting became known, many other observers confirmed the existence of these unique dark rifts through instruments as small as 6 inches (15cm) aperture. But as photography diminished the need for accurate visual observations, the M13 propeller became lost in the glow of the intense core.

Above: Stoney's sketch of M13. The breadth of the blades is greatly exaggerated, but the overall shape is correct.

 

Walter Scott Houston resurrected Stoney's dark lanes in his Deep-Sky Wonders column back in the July 1953 issue of Sky & Telescope magazine. His mention garnered little response at the time, however.  But thanks to his persistence, along with the Dobsonian revolution, the propeller started to become a popular challenge in the 1980s. Today, another three decades later, many of today's amateurs have seen the M13 propeller.

Most photographs of M13 do not show the propeller, however, because the cluster's core is usually so overexposed that they are absorbed into the glow. Yet by using a shorter exposure geared to resolve the core, the propeller can be seen.  I took the photograph here several years ago through a 100mm apochromatic refractor that I was reviewing for Astronomy magazine at the time.

Above: M13's propeller is visible in this image taken by the author through a 100mm apochromatic refractor.

For a successful visual sighting, magnification is key. Too low and the lanes will remain hidden from view.  To see the lanes for yourself, wait until the cluster is high in the sky, away from any haze and light pollution, which can stifle them. Under ideal conditions, the dark lanes are evident through a 12-inch, joined at their ends to resemble the corporate logo of a famous German auto maker -- proving once again that M13 is the Mercedes-Benz of globular clusters.

Have a favorite challenge object of your own?  I'd love to hear about it, as well as how you did with this month's test.  Contact me through my web site or post to this e-column's discussion forum.

Remember, half of the fun is the thrill of the chase.  Game on!



About the Author:

Phil Harrington writes the monthly Binocular Universe column in Astronomy magazine and is the author of 9 books on astronomy.  Visit his web site at www.philharrington.net to learn more.

Phil Harrington's Cosmic Challenge is copyright 2017 by Philip S. Harrington.  All rights reserved.  No reproduction, in whole or in part, beyond single copies for use by an individual, is permitted without written permission of the copyright holder.

 


  • okiestarman56 likes this


32 Comments

Photo
Phillip Creed
Jul 28 2017 08:34 AM

I had an interesting view of M13 and NGC 6207 through a 20" Obsession Dob and a 20mm Lunt 100 degree eyepiece at Stellafane last Thursday night.  Both were visible simultaneously.

 

BTW, the Propeller has been sighted in some surprisingly small apertures and at magnifications lower than I'd previously believed possible.

 

https://www.cloudyni...low-can-you-go/ (see post #11)

 

Dave Mitsky

I figured 6" - 8" was the minimum for a while until I read that particular post.  I still found it a bit hard to believe.  But I was able to see the Propeller under dark skies last month with a 4.5" refractor @ 125X.   I can't see it with the refractor under my brighter backyard skies (NLM ~ 5.5), but the 8" shows it with ease from there once you know where to look.

Clear Skies,

Phil 

Not bad there, Phil!  I'll have to drag out my venerable RV-8 sometime before M13 leaves us and try my luck.  Can't recall ever noticing it before, but then, maybe I wasn't looking carefully enough.

 

 

 

I had an interesting view of M13 and NGC 6207 through a 20" Obsession Dob and a 20mm Lunt 100 degree eyepiece at Stellafane last Thursday night.  Both were visible simultaneously.

 

BTW, the Propeller has been sighted in some surprisingly small apertures and at magnifications lower than I'd previously believed possible.

 

https://www.cloudyni...low-can-you-go/ (see post #11)

 

Dave Mitsky

I figured 6" - 8" was the minimum for a while until I read that particular post.  I still found it a bit hard to believe.  But I was able to see the Propeller under dark skies last month with a 4.5" refractor @ 125X.   I can't see it with the refractor under my brighter backyard skies (NLM ~ 5.5), but the 8" shows it with ease from there once you know where to look.

Clear Skies,

Phil 

 

Hi, I see more than one propeller in the photos. There is another propeller pattern on the opposite side of the cluster. I can also see others depending on the photo. These patterns are caused by foreground dust filaments that criss cross in front of the cluster. It might be an interesting challenge for people to try to see as many as possible and tell us what size scope they did it with.

I don't see nothing but a ball of stars with my 10". If they only show up in photos don't you think they are photo enhancement artifacts?

I've been seeing it without realizing it time and time again, but never really paid particular attention to it until I heard about the "propeller." It's quite obvious through my 15-inch, and still noticeable through my 10-inch. It is most definitely not some sort of artifact, it does appear consistently in photos from professional observatories and amateur astronomer's photos too. Exactly what is the nature of the "propeller" is a good question. There has been a theory that the "propeller" is actually a small dark nebula between Earth and M-13 that otherwise would be invisible but for the fact the bright core of a globular cluster is the perfect backdrop for it to reveal itself. I do not know if anyone has further pursued the question about what is the physical nature, or indeed is the "propeller" a real object or some sort of illusion.

 

Taras

 

I don't see nothing but a ball of stars with my 10". If they only show up in photos don't you think they are photo enhancement artifacts?

I've been seeing it without realizing it time and time again, but never really paid particular attention to it until I heard about the "propeller." It's quite obvious through my 15-inch, and still noticeable through my 10-inch. It is most definitely not some sort of artifact, it does appear consistently in photos from professional observatories and amateur astronomer's photos too. Exactly what is the nature of the "propeller" is a good question. There has been a theory that the "propeller" is actually a small dark nebula between Earth and M-13 that otherwise would be invisible but for the fact the bright core of a globular cluster is the perfect backdrop for it to reveal itself. I do not know if anyone has further pursued the question about what is the physical nature, or indeed is the "propeller" a real object or some sort of illusion.

 

Taras

 

The consensus is that these are real dust patterns. The only issue under discussion is whether or not the dust is inside the globular clusters or foreground dust seen in projection. I discuss this in the following link and conclude that it is foreground dust since the filaments can be seen crossing from one side of the cluster to the other and in the surrounding star fields.http://www.naturalph...ust-filaments/ 

 

Similar dust patterns have been detected by me in many different types of photos of different objects. One interesting example of criss crossing dust filaments is the X pattern in front of the nucleus of M51 which is misinterpreted as two Black Hole disks. See this link: http://www.naturalph...xy-photographs/

    • Dave Mitsky likes this
Photo
John O'Hara
Aug 02 2017 07:25 PM

 

I had an interesting view of M13 and NGC 6207 through a 20" Obsession Dob and a 20mm Lunt 100 degree eyepiece at Stellafane last Thursday night.  Both were visible simultaneously.

 

BTW, the Propeller has been sighted in some surprisingly small apertures and at magnifications lower than I'd previously believed possible.

 

https://www.cloudyni...low-can-you-go/ (see post #11)

 

Dave Mitsky

I figured 6" - 8" was the minimum for a while until I read that particular post.  I still found it a bit hard to believe.  But I was able to see the Propeller under dark skies last month with a 4.5" refractor @ 125X.   I can't see it with the refractor under my brighter backyard skies (NLM ~ 5.5), but the 8" shows it with ease from there once you know where to look.

Clear Skies,

Phil 

 

I've never attempted it with anything that small, and I've taken it as gospel from Scotty's Deep Sky Wonders​ that magnifications around 200x are needed.  I'm heading out to dark sky country during the eclipse and I'll give it a go in my 100 Pro ED refractor.  Who knows!  By the way, congratulations on the observation!

test - ignore this - I still don't know how to import an image  Tom



Cloudy Nights LLC
Cloudy Nights Sponsor: Astronomics