Not sure I would label separating imagers and visual astronomers as "distasteful." What's distasteful is the acrimony between the two camps, which may or may not be resolvable .....
Wow! I'd have to cut myself in half! I've been doing both - often at the same time - since 1961. Half my friends do both, including at star parties. I'm not seeing a lot of 'acrimony' - yes, some annoyance, and a few with major 'issues'. I do think there's a need for some 'education' on light discipline - a fine example of what a star party can provide. I've had plenty of problems with fellow visual observers at Cherry Springs - like people setting up a C-8 right next to my 20-inch Dob - no idea how big a circle a 20-inch Dob sweeps out at night -- or people parking next to, or on top of, one of the observing pads - and then not using it!
Star parties going away? I don't think so. If anything, the numbers are increasing. Plus, if you attend a "star party" you need to realize that you will have to accept some 'compromise' on expected conditions - as expected when attending an event that is aimed at more than just the 'advanced and dedicated astro hobbyist' and one will be dealing with a collection of several hundred people packed together.
If -- you want better conditions at Cherry Springs - do what many do -- arrive several days early or stay a few days later. Or come on a weekend with some moon late or early - or even better - mid-week. Plus, you don't lose any $$ if bad weather forces a cancelation.
I've done some of my best visual observing (and imaging) at Cherry Springs before/after a star party (maybe 20% the number of people on the field) or mid-week nights - when I've been totally alone. Some friends were at CSSP just recently - had 'moon' after around 1:30 or 2am - some transparency issues from smoke - but generally a fine time. I wish I could have joined them!
Edited by George N, 31 July 2024 - 10:51 AM.