Comet ISON_Please...
#76
Posted 08 November 2013 - 03:25 PM
Thanks for the link to the charts!
Looks like Stellarium has the magnitude reversed for ISON and Lovejoy. It says ISON is 6.18 and Lovejoy is 8.97
http://cometchasing.skyhound.com/ says ISON is between 8.1 and 7.7 and Lovejoy is between 6.7 and 5.1
#77
Posted 09 November 2013 - 02:32 PM
Tony Flanders, I really enjoy seeing you comment in these threads!
#78
Posted 10 November 2013 - 12:36 PM
#79
Posted 12 November 2013 - 06:36 PM
One the bright side of things there is yet another comet to add to the list in the AM sky; Comet C/2013 V3 (Nevski)is between Leo and Cancer or Cancer and Leo. Here is the link to a finder chart for the new comer:
http://cometchasing....ets/2013_V3.pdf
The AM sky is getting rather crowded with Solar Dust Bunnies (5 at last count).
#80
Posted 13 November 2013 - 12:19 PM
#81
Posted 13 November 2013 - 02:34 PM
Comet Ison maybe brighter than the average bear but even I as a newbie amateur astronomer knew not to expect a "brilliant, dazzling, blindingly and bright comet in the sky" or the "comet of the century" as people imagine it should be.
Even the most optimistic predictions wouldn't have made Comet ISON dazzling at this point. Realistically, the best we could possibly have expected in mid-November was a comet much like Lovejoy -- faintly visible to the unaided eye from dark locations, and quite impressive through binoculars.
All that "Comet of the Century" stuff was supposed to happen at or immediately after perihelion, in late November and early December. And in fact, it's still possible that it may put on a good naked-eye show in early December.
Comet of the Century? That was always stretching the facts, even in the most optimistic scenario.
#82
Posted 13 November 2013 - 03:44 PM
Are these your first comets to observe?
#83
Posted 13 November 2013 - 03:53 PM
#84
Posted 14 November 2013 - 08:59 AM
(like Hyakutake for example) this initial outer layer of ice and dust has blown off a long time ago.
So even if it doesn't perform as brilliantly as we anticipated, it's still a significant visitor. It is a good chance to see a comet that is making its first journey from the Oort Cloud. When showing it to the public, or explaining it to non astronomy types.. I try to emphasize this aspect of the comets significance. If you think about it.. It's really a comet of many centuries.
#85
Posted 14 November 2013 - 01:11 PM
A time-lapse video of the comet rising this morning is posted at http://blog.cajunastro.com/?cat=6
See http://www.skyandtel...mes-to-Life-... for additional information.
Dave Mitsky
#86
Posted 14 November 2013 - 02:19 PM
It is probably the only comet we will ever get to see, that is making its first journey from the Oort Cloud.
I don't think that's right; freshly arrived comets are quite common.
In general, it's impossible to tell for sure, because the difference between a million-year orbit and one coming in fresh from infinity (the Oort Cloud counts as infinity) is too small to measure. For that matter, we typically can't rule out the possibility that they arrived from beyond the Oort Cloud, from interstellar space. But as far as I know, no asteroid or comet has ever been confirmed for sure as an interstellar visitor.
Note that orbits get perturbed by the planets, especially Jupiter. So something that starts out as a fresh arrival may end up as a periodic comet -- or be ejected entirely from the solar system.
#87
Posted 14 November 2013 - 02:55 PM
So even if it doesn't perform as brilliantly as we anticipated, it's still a significant visitor. It is probably the only comet we will ever get to see, that is making its first journey from the Oort Cloud. When showing it to the public, or explaining it to non astronomy types.. I try to emphasize this aspect of the comets significance. If you think about it.. It's really the comet of many centuries.
In fact, comets from the Oort Cloud are really not all that uncommon. I've watched many of them come and go over the years. This is why, if you listen to the right people, you will have heard months ago that ISON could never possibly developed as first publicized (i.e. brighter than the full moon). Actually, it is performing rather similarly to most of its previous Oort Cloud brethren, except perhaps for today's major outburst. Comet Kohoutek was a dynamically "new" comet, as was more recent Comet Austin in 1989; both heralded as likely to become comet's of the century, which neither did.
Likewise, the unperturbed orbital elements of a comet prior to its entering the realm of the planets can be calculated given a long enough observed arc of the orbit. Even those with million year periods can show a just detectible deviation from e=1.0 and most Oort Cloud comets can even be slightly hyperbolic. However, a true interstellar comet is anticipated to be highly hyperbolic and this has never been seen.
BrooksObs
#88
Posted 14 November 2013 - 05:08 PM
I'd probably have to set up at a local park, which would have some significant ambient light pollution.
#89
Posted 14 November 2013 - 05:30 PM
#90
Posted 14 November 2013 - 06:56 PM
So, at this point, is ISON or Lovejoy bright enough to be seen by a 60mm refractor (the same one from the $24.99 refractor thread)? The skies in my area are *BLEEP*, and because of that I don't feel like taking the 70 mile round trip to my dark site for observing.
I'd probably have to set up at a local park, which would have some significant ambient light pollution.
Both comets should be visible through a 60mm refractor.
Dave Mitsky
#91
Posted 14 November 2013 - 07:10 PM
#92
Posted 14 November 2013 - 07:30 PM
So, at this point, is ISON or Lovejoy bright enough to be seen by a 60mm refractor (the same one from the $24.99 refractor thread)?
Easily. I saw Lovejoy on Wednesday morning from my local city park through 10x30 binoculars. I was expecting to have to work at it, but in fact the comet was instantly obvious -- quite bright, really -- as soon as I started sweeping the area.
By all reports, ISON is now (or was this morning) even brighter than Lovejoy. However, it's also much lower in the sky, which is a definitely handicap.
#93
Posted 15 November 2013 - 07:01 AM
#94
Posted 15 November 2013 - 07:49 AM
So, at this point, is ISON or Lovejoy bright enough to be seen by a 60mm refractor?
Lovejoy has been easy in my 12x60 binos. ISON was a struggle until this morning (I didn't go out yesterday) but this morning it was instantly obvious in the 12x60s even though three inconsiderate neighbors had left their porch lights on. As an experiment, I went inside and grabbed my 7x50s and both were also easy in the 7x50s. I would say Lovejoy is more fan-shaped than ISON--ISON's tail was more "spikey" to me in the binos. I could see about 1.5 degrees of it in the 12x60s handheld (probably more if I hadn't been too lazy to set up a tripod).
So you should have no trouble in a 60mm scope at low power. Just do it soon as you don't have too much "dark of the moon" left.
Come to think of it, I should have looked for Nevski too but morning twilight is already upon us here in Colorado. Oh well.
#95
Posted 15 November 2013 - 07:50 AM
Comet of the Century? That was always stretching the facts, even in the most optimistic scenario.
Well, it's been a short century so far.
#96
Posted 15 November 2013 - 08:14 AM
Comet of the Century? That was always stretching the facts, even in the most optimistic scenario.
Well, it's been a short century so far.
Yeah, but McNaught C/2006 P1 has already set a pretty high bar.
#97
Posted 15 November 2013 - 08:26 AM
I was wondering if someone has give a try at Lovejoy in the evening as Stellarium indicate Lovejoy rising NE at 10.30pm ET?
#98
Posted 15 November 2013 - 08:31 AM
I was wondering if someone has give a try at Lovejoy in the evening as Stellarium indicate Lovejoy rising NE at 10.30pm ET?
Since it's just about straight overhead at 5:00 AM, it should be easy at about 1:30. The trouble is, you'll have the Moon to contend with.
#99
Posted 15 November 2013 - 07:19 PM
#100
Posted 16 November 2013 - 04:16 AM
Then best you check out the latest images from Mr Damian Peach , they are stunning ...
http://www.damianpea...013_11_15dp.jpg
http://www.damianpea...11_15dp_neg.jpg
I just hope it survives its encounter with the Sun and emerges on the other side intact and ready to put on a show.